Ancestral dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT) exposure promotes epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of obesity
© Skinner et al.; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2013
Received: 15 May 2013
Accepted: 27 September 2013
Published: 23 October 2013
Ancestral environmental exposures to a variety of environmental factors and toxicants have been shown to promote the epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of adult onset disease. The present work examined the potential transgenerational actions of the insecticide dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT) on obesity and associated disease.
Outbred gestating female rats were transiently exposed to a vehicle control or DDT and the F1 generation offspring bred to generate the F2 generation and F2 generation bred to generate the F3 generation. The F1 and F3 generation control and DDT lineage rats were aged and various pathologies investigated. The F3 generation male sperm were collected to investigate methylation between the control and DDT lineage male sperm.
The F1 generation offspring (directly exposed as a fetus) derived from the F0 generation exposed gestating female rats were not found to develop obesity. The F1 generation DDT lineage animals did develop kidney disease, prostate disease, ovary disease and tumor development as adults. Interestingly, the F3 generation (great grand-offspring) had over 50% of males and females develop obesity. Several transgenerational diseases previously shown to be associated with metabolic syndrome and obesity were observed in the testis, ovary and kidney. The transgenerational transmission of disease was through both female (egg) and male (sperm) germlines. F3 generation sperm epimutations, differential DNA methylation regions (DMR), induced by DDT were identified. A number of the genes associated with the DMR have previously been shown to be associated with obesity.
Observations indicate ancestral exposure to DDT can promote obesity and associated disease transgenerationally. The etiology of disease such as obesity may be in part due to environmentally induced epigenetic transgenerational inheritance.
KeywordsEnvironmental epigenetics Metabolic syndrome Obesity associated disease Epimutations Disease etiology Maternal transmission
A number of environmental factors such as toxicants and nutrition have been shown to promote the epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of adult onset disease and phenotypic variation [1–3]. Examples of environmental compounds include the fungicide vinclozolin [4–6], plasticizers bisphenol-A (BPA) and phthalates , dioxin [7–9], hydrocarbons [7, 8], and pesticides [4, 7, 8]. Nutritional abnormalities such as caloric restriction and high-fat diets can also promote transgenerational phenotypes . Epigenetic transgenerational inheritance involves the germline (sperm or egg) transgenerational transmission of epigenetic marks that influence physiological parameters and disease, in the absence of direct environmental exposures [1, 3]. This phenomenon has been observed in plants , flies , worms , rodents , and humans . Therefore, your ancestors’ environmental exposures may influence your disease development, even though you have never had a direct exposure. Environmentally induced epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of disease appears to be a factor in disease etiology that needs to be considered and elucidated.
The present study was designed to examine the potential transgenerational actions of the most common historically used insecticide dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT) [15, 16]. DDT has been banned from the USA, but is used globally as an insecticide for control of vectors for malaria and visceral leishmaniasis. DDT is 1 of the 12 chemicals proposed for elimination by the 2001 Stockholm Convention of United Nations Environmental Program . However, DDT use in Africa has increased since the Stockholm Convention due to the recent Gates Foundation Malaria Control Program . The reported global use of DDT for disease vector control is 4,000 to 5,000 metric tons per year, with India being by far the largest consumer . In 2006, the World Health Organization issued a position statement promoting the use of indoor residual spraying with DDT for malaria vector control. Although DDT is a low-cost antimalarial tool, the possible adverse human health and environmental effects of exposure must be carefully weighed against the benefits to malaria control . Recent evidence indicates that indoor spraying causes high levels of human exposure to DDT . The direct exposure toxic effects of DDT in humans have been reviewed  and include reproductive disease , neurological disease , developmental abnormalities , and cancer . Studies have also shown DDT’s potential to cause birth defects in wildlife . Exposure to DDT and its breakdown product dichlorodiphenyldichloroethylene (DDE) may be associated with adverse health outcomes such as diabetes and obesity in children [26, 27].
The dramatic increase in obesity over the past 50 years has suggested environmental factors are important in the disease etiology. The prevalence of obesity has increased substantially since the mid-20th century with an accelerated rate of increase in the 1980s . The US Centers for Disease Control in 2010 reported that 33% of adults in the US are obese and 17% of children between ages 2 to 19 are obese. Obesity has not only increased in the US, but also increased in virtually every country where detailed data are available . The primary causal factor suggested is overnutrition , however, recent studies have suggested environmental toxicants  such as plastics [30, 31], hydrocarbons , and tributyltin  can promote obesity in rodents. Although overnutrition and reduced physical activity are critical elements of the disease, other contributing factors include maternal age, endocrine disruptors, sleep deprivation, pharmaceutical introgenesis, ambient temperature, and intrauterine and intergenerational effects . All these contributing factors have been shown to be involved in obesity, but the underlying molecular mechanisms are unclear. Genetic abnormalities have been identified in a number of the genes associated with obesity [34, 35], however, no significant genome-wide associations have been shown to correlate with the majority of obese individuals . In addition, no known genetic mechanism could explain the rapid increase in the incidence of obesity in the last 30 years. Clearly, genetics will be a critical aspect of any disease, including obesity, but it simply cannot explain many of the elements of the disease etiology. An alternate consideration is the role of environmental epigenetics in obesity  and in the developmental origins of disease . The present study further investigates the role of epigenetics in the etiology of obesity.
Obesity is now known to be associated with a number of different clinical conditions in a complex disease trait known as metabolic syndrome . Although a number of diseases have associations, the functional link and correlation remains to be elucidated. Predominant associated conditions are insulin resistance  and polycystic ovarian disease . Other obesity-associated conditions include type 2 diabetes , non-alcoholic fatty liver disease , obstructive sleep apnea , kidney/renal disease  and testis disease and male infertility . The scientific literature suggests over 50% of females with polycystic ovarian disease are obese [45, 46]. Therefore, polycystic ovarian disease and several other diseases that are associated with obesity are also investigated in the present study.
Although the direct exposure toxicity of DDT is documented , no previous transgenerational studies involving DDT exposure have been reported. The present study tests the hypothesis that DDT promotes the epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of obesity and associated disease. In the event DDT ancestral exposures promote obesity in subsequent generations, in the absence of any direct exposures, the biohazards of DDT are significantly greater than anticipated. It may be that ancestral exposures to environmental toxicants such as DDT have a significant role in the etiology of the obesity observed in the current human population. Interestingly, the F3 generation of the majority of the gestating women exposed in the 1950s in the USA are adults today. The elucidation of the epigenetic biomarkers and molecular mechanisms involved in this environmentally induced epigenetic transgenerational inheritance is anticipated to lead to new diagnostics and therapeutics for obesity and associated diseases.
Animal studies and breeding
Female and male rats of an outbred strain Hsd:Sprague Dawley®™SD®™ Harlan (Indianapolis, IN) at about 70 and 100 days of age were fed ad libitum with a standard rat diet and ad lib tap water for drinking. To obtain time-pregnant females, the female rats in proestrus were pair mated with male rats. The sperm-positive (day 0) rats were monitored for diestrus and body weight. On days 8 to 14 of gestation , the females were administered daily intraperitoneal injections of DDT (either 50 or 25 mg/kg BW/day) or dimethyl sulfoxide (vehicle). The p,p’-DDT was obtained from Sigma (St Louis, MO, USA) (no. PS699) and was injected in a 20 μl dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO)/oil vehicle as previously described . Treatment lineages are designated ‘control’, ‘DDT’ or ‘lower’ dose DDT lineages. This is not meant to represent a ‘low’ dose analysis. The gestating female rats treated were designated as the F0 generation. The offspring of the F0 generation rats were the F1 generation. Non-littermate females and males aged 70 to 90 days from F1 generation of control, DDT or low dose DDT lineages were bred to obtain F2 generation offspring. The F2 generation rats were bred to obtain F3 generation offspring. Outcross F4 generation offspring (n = 8 litters per lineage) were obtained by breeding the F3 generation males from control and low dose DDT lineages with wild type females. Reverse outcross F4 generation progeny (n = 8 litters per lineage) were obtained by breeding the F3 generation females from control and low dose DDT lineages with wild type males. The outcross and the reverse outcross individuals were maintained until 10 months of age and then euthanized for tissue collection and disease evaluation. The F1 to F4 generation offspring were not themselves treated directly with DDT. The control and DDT lineages were housed in the same room and racks with lighting, food and water as previously described [1, 5, 7]. All experimental protocols for the procedures with rats were preapproved by the Washington State University Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC approval no. 02568–029).
Tissue harvest and histology processing
Rats at 10 to 12 months of age were euthanized by CO2 inhalation for tissue harvest. Body and organ weights were measured at dissection time. No significant changes in body weight were observed within this 2-month period and statistical analysis did not identify this as a confounder in the analysis. Testis, epididymis, prostate, seminal vesicle, ovaries, uterus and kidney were fixed in Bouin’s solution (Sigma) and 70% ethanol, then processed for paraffin embedding by standard procedures for histopathology examination. Tissue sections of 5 μm were made and were either unstained and used for terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick-end labeling (TUNEL) analysis or stained with hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) stain and examined for histopathology. Blood samples were collected at the time of dissection, allowed to clot, centrifuged and serum samples stored for steroid hormone assays.
Histopathology examination and disease classification
Obesity was assessed with an increase in body weight and marked abdominal adiposity. The obesity classification has been defined as these abnormalities and the presence of associated pathologies [28, 36, 49–51]. Testis histopathology criteria included the presence of a vacuole, azoospermic atretic seminiferous tubule and ‘other’ abnormalities including sloughed spermatogenic cells in center of the tubule and a lack of a tubule lumen. Testis sections were examined by TUNEL assay (in situ cell death detection kit, Fluorescein, Roche Diagnostics, Mannheim, Germany). Prostate histopathology criteria included the presence of vacuoles, atrophic epithelial layer of ducts and hyperplasia of prostatic duct epithelium as previously described [52, 53]. No prostatic intraepithelial neoplasia (PIN) lesions were observed in the prostates. Kidney histopathology criteria included reduced size of glomerulus, thickened Bowman’s capsule and the presence of proteinaceous fluid-filled cysts. A cut-off was established to declare a tissue ‘diseased’ based on the mean number of histopathological abnormalities plus 2 standard deviations from the mean of control tissues by each of the three individual observers. This number was used to classify rats into those with and without testis, prostate or kidney disease in each lineage. A rat tissue section was finally declared ‘diseased’ only when at least two of the three observers marked the same tissue section ‘diseased’. The proportion of rats with obesity or tumor development was obtained by accounting those that had these conditions out of all the animals evaluated.
Ovary sections were stained with H&E stain and three stained sections (150 μm apart) through the central portion of the ovary with the largest cross section were evaluated. Ovary sections were assessed for two diseases, primordial follicle loss and polycystic ovary disease. Primordial follicle loss was determined by counting the number of primordial follicles per ovary section and averaging across three sections. An animal was scored as having primordial follicle loss if the primordial follicle number was less than that of the control mean minus 2 standard deviations. Primordial follicles had an oocyte surrounded by a single layer of either squamous or both squamous and cuboidal granulosa cells [8, 54]. Follicles had to be non-atretic and showing an oocyte nucleus in order to be counted. Polycystic ovary was determined by microscopically counting the number of small cystic structures per section averaged across three sections. A polycystic ovary was defined as having a number of small cysts that was more than the control mean plus 2 standard deviations. Cysts were defined as fluid-filled structures of a specified size that were not filled with red blood cells and which were not follicular antra. A single layer of cells may line cysts. Small cysts were 50 to 250 μm in diameter measured from the inner cellular boundary across the longest axis. Percentages of females with primordial follicle loss or polycystic ovarian disease were computed.
Overall disease incidence
A table of the incidence of individual diseases in rats from each lineage was created and the proportion of individual disease, total disease and multiple disease incidences was computed. For the individual diseases, only those rats that showed a presence of disease (plus) or absence of disease (minus) are included in the computation. For the total diseases, a column with total number of diseases for each rat was created and the number of plus signs were added up for each of the rats and the proportion was computed as the number of rats with total disease out of all the listed rats. For the multiple diseases, the proportion was computed as the number of rats with multiple diseases out of all the listed rats.
Epididymal sperm collection and DNA isolation and methylated DNA immunoprecipitation
The epididymis was dissected free of connective tissue, a small cut made to the cauda and placed in 5 ml of F12 culture medium containing 0.1% bovine serum albumin for 10 minutes at 37°C and then kept at 4°C to immobilize the sperm. The epididymal tissue was minced and the released sperm centrifuged at 13,000 g and stored in fresh nuclear isolation medium (NIM) buffer at −20°C until processed further. Sperm heads were separated from tails through sonication following previously described protocol (without protease inhibitors)  and then purified using a series of washes and centrifugations  from a total of nine F3 generation rats per lineage (control or DDT) that were 120 days of age. DNA extraction on the purified sperm heads was performed as described . Equal concentrations of DNA from three individual sperm samples were used to produce three DNA pools per lineage and employed for chromatin immunoprecipitation of methylated DNA fragments (MeDIP). MeDIP was performed as previously described [7, 57].
The comparative MeDIP-chip was performed with Roche Nimblegen’s Rat DNA Methylation 3 × 720 K CpG Island Plus RefSeq Promoter Array which contains 3 identical subarrays, with 720,000 probes per subarray, scanning a total of 15,287 promoters (3,880 bp upstream and 970 bp downstream from transcription start site). Probe sizes range from 50 to 75 bp in length with the median probe spacing of 100 bp. Three different comparative (MeDIP vs MeDIP) hybridization experiments were performed (three subarrays) for DDT lineage versus control, with each subarray encompassing DNA samples from six animals (three each from DDT and control). MeDIP DNA samples from experimental lineages were labeled with Cy3 and MeDIP DNA samples from the control lineage were labeled with Cy5. Selected differential DNA methylation regions (DMR) identified with the MeDIP-chip analysis were confirmed with a MeDIP-quantitative polymerase chain reaction (QPCR) analysis involving real-time PCR analysis of the MeDIP samples as previously described [31, 32].
Bioinformatic and statistical analyses of MeDIP-chip data
The bioinformatic analysis was performed as previously described [7, 57]. The statistical analysis was performed in pairs of comparative immunoprecipitation hybridizations between DDT (D) and controls (C) (for example, D1-C1 and D2-C2, D1-C1 and D3-C3, D2-C2 and D3-C3). In order to assure the reproducibility of the candidates obtained, only the candidates showing significant changes in all of the single paired comparisons (intersection) were chosen as a having a significant change in DNA methylation between DDT lineage and control lineage. This is a very stringent approach to select for changes, since it only considers repeated changes in all paired analysis. The statistically significant differential DNA methylated regions were identified and P value associated with each region presented. Each region of interest was then annotated for gene and CpG content. This list was further reduced to those regions with an average intensity value exceeding 9.5 (log scale) and a CpG density ≥1 CpG/100 bp.
Statistical analysis of rat organ and disease data
Individual animals from different litters were used for analysis and n values presented for all experiments. For statistical analysis, all the continuous data on body and organ weights and apoptosis were used as input in the program GraphPad Prism 5 statistical analysis program and t tests were used to determine if the data from the DDT lineages differ from those of control lineages. For the number of rats with or without disease, logistic regression analysis was used to analyze the data (control or DDT and diseased or unaffected). A simple logistic regression was performed using an online calculator tool (http://vassarstats.net/logreg1.html). The binary outcome variable was diseased/not diseased (for example, obese/non-obese). The predictor variable was treatment (control vs DDT and control vs LD DDT) and each was performed separately for the analysis. Each treatment group was only compared to its own control using the numbers of affected/non-affected individuals evaluated for each treatment group. All treatment differences were considered significant if the P value was less than 0.05.
Transgenerational obesity and associated disease analysis
The transgenerational actions of control (vehicle DMSO), DDT (50 mg/kg body weight) and a lower dose (LD) DDT (25 mg/kg BW) administered female rats (F0 generation) during days 8 to 14 of gestation were investigated. The doses of DDT used are anticipated environmental exposures [22, 58]. The F1 (direct exposure) and F3 (transgenerational) generation rats of control, DDT and lower dose DDT lineages were aged to 1 year and euthanized for analysis. The testis, prostate, kidney, ovary and uterus were collected and examined for histopathologies. To assess if there was any direct fetal exposure toxicity to DDT the F1 generation litter size, sex ratio, body weights and organ weights were measured (Additional file 1: Table S1A). No effect was observed on litter size or sex ratio (P >0.05). The body weights of the F1 generation DDT and LD DDT were slightly reduced, while several organ weights were slightly increased. Therefore, no overt toxicity to DDT was observed in the direct in utero exposed F1 generation lineages.
The incidence of ovarian disease in DDT and LD DDT lineages is presented in Figure 3d. An increase in ovarian disease was observed in both the F1 and F3 generation DDT lineages. The primary ovarian disease detected was the development of polycystic ovaries with an increase in the number of small and large cysts as previously described  (Figure 3e). In contrast to previous environmental toxicants examined , no effect on primordial follicle numbers were detected in the DDT or LD DDT lineages (Figure 3f). The increase in ovarian disease in the F3 generation DDT and LD DDT lineages observed was primarily characterized by the development of ovarian cysts. Analysis of estradiol levels in the proestrous or diestrous F3 generation females revealed this was not changed in the DDT or LD DDT lineages (Additional file 3: Figure S2C,D). Therefore, DDT and LD DDT were found to promote the obesity-associated transgenerational polycystic ovarian disease.
The incidence of kidney disease in DDT and LD DDT lineages is presented in Figure 3g and 3h. Kidney disease was characterized by the presence of an increased number of proteinaceous fluid filled cysts, reduction in size of glomeruli and thickening of Bowman’s capsules (Additional file 2: Figure S1B). There was an increase in female kidney disease in F1 and F3 generation LD DDT lineage, but only in the F1 generation in the DDT lineage (Figure 3g). The males showed a dramatic increase with over 60% of the F1 and F3 generation animals in the LD DDT lineage affected (Figure 3h). Therefore, DDT was found to promote the obesity-associated transgenerational kidney disease in both males and females.
Additional potential obesity-associated disease and abnormalities (Figure 2) investigated were prostate disease , pubertal abnormalities , tumor development  and immune abnormalities . Prostate disease was examined in the F1 and F3 generation males (Additional file 2: Figure S1 and Table S2A). Prostate disease was characterized by atrophic prostate duct epithelium and hyperplasia (Additional file 2: Figure S1A) as previously described . The incidence of prostate disease increased in F1 generation males of DDT and LD DDT lineages, but no effect was observed in the F3 generation males. Therefore, no transgenerational prostate disease was observed. In addition, no influence on F3 generation male testosterone levels was observed (Additional file 3: Figure S2E). Analysis of the onset of puberty, as previously described , was found not to be altered in either females (Additional file 3: Figure S2F) or males (Additional file 3: Figure S2G) in the F1 or F3 generations. The incidence of tumor development was monitored and the primary tumors observed were mammary tumors, as previously described . No altered tumor development was observed in the F1 or F3 generation females (Additional file 3: Figure S2H). An increase in tumor development was observed in the F1 generation DDT lineage males, but no effect was observed in the F3 generation lineages (Additional file 3: Figure S2I). Therefore, no transgenerational influence was observed for prostate disease, pubertal abnormalities or tumor development. Analysis of the uterus identified a significant increase in uterine infection in the F3 generation DDT lineage females, with over 70% of the animals affected (Additional file 3: Figure S2B). Uterine infection was determined by the enlargement of uterus, accumulation of foul-smelling dark discolored purulent material and presence of inflammation within the uterine horns. Therefore, potential transgenerational immune abnormalities were detected in the females.
The incidence of multiple disease and abnormalities (≥2) per rat was determined (Figure 3i,j). The incidence of diseases in individual rats from control, DDT and LD DDT lineages are presented in Additional file 4: Table S2 for F1 generation females (S2A) and males (S2B), and in Additional file 5: Table S3 for F3 generation females (S3A) and males (S3B). The incidence of multiple diseases in F1 generation females increased in the DDT lineage, while the incidence in the F3 generation females increased in approximately 50% of the animals in the DDT and LD DDT lineages (Figure 3i). The incidence of multiple disease in the F1 generation males increased in the LD DDT lineage, while the incidence in the F3 generation males increased to affect approximately 60% of the animals in the DDT and LD DDT lineages (Figure 3j). Therefore, exposure of F0 generation females to two different doses of DDT increased the incidence of obesity and associated multiple diseases in the F1 and F3 generation male and female progeny.
Parental germline transmission of DDT-induced transgenerational obesity and associated disease
An experiment was designed to determine if the epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of adult onset obesity and associated disease is transmitted through the male (sperm) and/or female (egg) germline. The F3 generation control and LD DDT lineage animals were outcrossed to wild-type animals to generate the F4 generation. The outcross (OC) involved an F3 generation male being crossed with a wild-type female and the reverse outcross (ROC) involved an F3 generation female being crossed with a wild-type male. The F4 generation animals were aged to 10 months and then sacrificed to assess transgenerational obesity and associated disease incidence as previously described (Additional file 6: Tables S4 and Additional file 7: Table S5).
Epigenetic transgenerational transmission of sperm epimutations
A previous study identified a unique genomic feature associated with the environmentally induced sperm DMR [7, 57]. The genomic feature identified in all transgenerational sperm DMR previously identified is a low-density CpG of less than 10 CpG/100 bp [7, 57]. These low-density regions are termed ‘CpG deserts’ that contain clusters of CpG . The DDT transgenerational sperm DMR were found to contain less than 15 CpG/100 bp, with 3 to 6 CpG/100 bp being the most predominant density (Figure 5c). Therefore, the low-density ‘CpG desert’ genomic feature was a component of the DDT F3 generation sperm DMR.
The present study demonstrates that ancestral DDT exposure during a critical window of germline development can promote the epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of obesity and a number of associated complex disease traits. The doses of DDT used have been shown to be wildlife and human environmental exposure levels [22, 58]. The human DDT lowest observed adverse effect level LOAEL is 0.25 mg/kg/day which is lower than that used in the present study. The objective of the present study was to determine the potential transgenerational actions of DDT, such that a higher dose was used initially. We administered through an intraperitoneal injection to determine the potential to promote phenotypes. Previous studies have shown intraperitoneal injection is less stressful than oral gavage and less problematic to promote indirect effects from mode of administration . Therefore, the present study was not designed as a risk assessment analysis for DDT exposures, but to determine the potential ability of DDT to promote transgenerational phenotypes. Future research can now use the information obtained to design risk assessment studies with more appropriate modes of administration for environmental doses. However, the observations do demonstrate the ability of ancestral DDT exposures to promote transgenerational adult onset obesity and associated disease.
The most dramatic increase in the incidence of adult onset disease observed was with obesity and was only in the F3 generation. Over 50% of the males and females with ancestral DDT exposure developed an obesity condition of increased body weight and abdominal adiposity. Previous reviews of the definition and cause for obesity suggest that weight gain, adiposity and presence of other obesity-associated disease is sufficient to refer to the pathology observed as obesity [28, 36, 49–51]. The US Centers for Disease Control in 2010 reported that 33% of adults in the US are obese and 17% of children between ages 2 to 19 are obese. Obesity is a contributing factor and/or precursor for many other diseases including polycystic ovarian disease, testis disease, kidney disease, liver disease, cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, and diminished average life expectancy  (Figure 2). The dramatic increase in obesity over the past 50 years suggests that environmental factors are important in the disease etiology. The primary causal factor suggested is overnutrition [28, 67, 68]. However, recent studies have suggested environmental toxicants such as plastics , jet fuel hydrocarbons , and tributyltin  can promote transgenerational obesity in rodents. Waterland and colleagues suggested that epigenetic mechanisms are involved in transgenerational transmission of maternal obesity . The present study demonstrated the epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of obesity in both males and females following an ancestral DDT exposure. The two obesity conditions of weight gain and abdominal adiposity are sufficient to identify obesity [28, 49, 50], however, future studies will need to assess the effects on other obesity parameters such as bone mineralization, body length and metabolic disease. Interestingly, several obesity-associated diseases were identified in the present study including polycystic ovarian disease, testis disease and kidney disease [9, 27, 44, 45, 69–72]. The obesity observed in humans and rodents have similar disease phenotypes and associations [28, 36]. The functional correlation of these diseases needs to be elucidated. Interestingly, the DDT-induced obesity was only observed in the F3 generation and not the F1 direct exposure generation. The molecular mechanisms involved in the F1 generation and F3 generation are distinct . The F1 generation pathology is due to direct exposure of the somatic cells of the fetus and does not involve the germline. The F3 generation pathology is due to a transgenerational germline mediated mechanism . The epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of obesity in the F3 generation is distinct from the somatic exposure mechanism of the F1 generation [1, 2]. Therefore, some germline mediated detrimental effects of DDT could be hidden for several generations before they become apparent. Observations suggest ancestral exposures to DDT may be a component of the rising incidence of obesity observed in the current human population. Since the primary human exposures to DDT in the US occurred in the 1950s, three generations have developed with a progressively increasing incidence of obesity in the population. Therefore, future studies are required to assess the importance of ancestral DDT exposures to the etiology of obesity.
The transgenerational obesity-associated diseases and abnormalities (Figure 2) observed include testis disease, polycystic ovarian disease, immune abnormalities and kidney disease. Direct DDT exposure has been shown to promote testis disease in rats (7.5 mg/kg/day for 36 weeks) , alligators , and fish . Interestingly, male offspring of women exposed to DDT during pregnancy had an increase in testis disease observed 30 years following the exposure . Polycystic ovarian disease is now the most common reproductive disease in women leading to infertility and endocrine abnormalities . A number of environmental compounds have the ability to promote transgenerational ovarian disease in rats . Kidney disease has been shown to be induced following direct DDT exposure in rats (10 mg/kg/day for 27 days)  and in humans . A number of environmental toxicants can promote transgenerational kidney disease in rats . All these diseases (that is, testis, ovary, and kidney) have increased dramatically over the past decades suggesting a potential environmental component. The presence of these associated diseases in the present study supports the conclusion that DDT exposure of a gestating female promotes the transgenerational inheritance of obesity and associated complex disease traits.
The environmentally induced epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of disease requires the germline transmission of epimutations to subsequent generations [1–4]. The present study identified the DDT-induced transgenerational epimutations in the sperm of the F3 generation males. A comparison of these differential DMR with DMR induced by other environmental toxicants  demonstrated a unique DDT DMR signature that may be used to assess ancestral DDT exposure. The DDT transgenerational DMR had a low-density CpG ‘CpG desert’ genomic feature, as previously described with other exposures [7, 57]. These low-density CpG deserts containing clusters of CpG are speculated to be a regulatory genomic feature associated with the DDT DMR. Further studies are needed to elucidate the functional significance of this DMR genomic feature. The presence of the F3 generation DMR demonstrates a transgenerational transmission of an epigenetic alteration in the germline. Future studies will need to compare the F3 generation DMR with the F1 and F2 generations. The present study demonstrates the epigenetic transmission and inheritance of sperm epimutations.
Analysis of the genes associated with the DDT sperm DMR identified a number of genes previously shown to be involved in obesity or the associated polycystic ovarian disease (Figure 6). The role of the DMR identified in the regulation of these correlated genes remains to be elucidated, however, these genes have previously been shown to be associated with obesity. Observations provide potential mechanistic links with the pathologies observed. Previous studies have shown that over 50% of females with polycystic ovarian disease are over weight or obese [45, 69, 70]. Therefore, a strong link exists between obesity and ovarian disease . Interestingly, the transmission of many of the DDT-induced disease states was found to be through the female germline. This is the first female-germline-transmitted transgenerational phenotype identified. The imprinted-like nature of the transgenerational phenotype  suggests a parent-of-origin allele specific transmission of disease, which has been shown to be either paternal or maternal. This molecular mechanism needs to be elucidated in future studies, but the present study demonstrates sex specific germline transmission of transgenerational phenotypes. Future studies are now needed to assess the DMR in the egg induced by DDT. Observations suggest a potential exposure and disease specificity to the parental origins of the transgenerational phenomena.
Over 50 years have passed since the publication of the book Silent Spring by Rachel Carson that argued the hazards of DDT to wildlife and human health . Since the Gates Foundation and World Health Organization (WHO) have now promoted the use of DDT in Africa and other developing countries for malaria control, the potential hazards of current day exposures now need to be considered in light of the transgenerational actions of DDT. Although the number of lives saved from malaria is significant, the long-term health and economic effects on survivors  and subsequent generations also need to be considered. Since other options exist with less toxic shorter half-life pesticides, a more careful risk/benefit consideration of the use of DDT is now needed.
The degree that environmentally induced epigenetic transgenerational inheritance is involved in human obesity and disease etiology is not known. However, since the majority of chronic diseases have increased dramatically over the past decades, environmental exposures and transgenerational epigenetics will likely be a component of disease etiology to seriously consider in the future. A more thorough and mechanistic understanding of the molecular etiology of disease, including the role of environmental epigenetics, is anticipated to provide insights into new diagnostics and therapeutics for specific diseases.
Differential DNA methylation regions
Methylated DNA immunoprecipitation.
We thank the expert technical assistance of Ms Elizabeth Houser, Ms Tiffany Hylkema, Ms Renee Espinosa Najera, Ms Jessica Shiflett, and Ms Colleen Johns, as well as the assistance of Ms Heather Johnson in the preparation of the manuscript. This study was supported by a grant from the NIH, NIEHS to MKS. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
- Skinner MK, Manikkam M, Guerrero-Bosagna C: Epigenetic transgenerational actions of environmental factors in disease etiology. Trends Endocrinol Metab. 2010, 21: 214-222.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Jirtle RL, Skinner MK: Environmental epigenomics and disease susceptibility. Nat Rev Genet. 2007, 8: 253-262.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Skinner MK: Environmental epigenetic transgenerational inheritance and somatic epigenetic mitotic stability. Epigenetics. 2011, 6: 838-842.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Anway MD, Cupp AS, Uzumcu M, Skinner MK: Epigenetic transgenerational actions of endocrine disruptors and male fertility. Science. 2005, 308: 1466-1469.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Anway MD, Leathers C, Skinner MK: Endocrine disruptor vinclozolin induced epigenetic transgenerational adult-onset disease. Endocrinology. 2006, 147: 5515-5523.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Stouder C, Paoloni-Giacobino A: Transgenerational effects of the endocrine disruptor vinclozolin on the methylation pattern of imprinted genes in the mouse sperm. Reproduction. 2010, 139: 373-379.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Manikkam M, Guerrero-Bosagna C, Tracey R, Haque MM, Skinner MK: Transgenerational Actions of Environmental Compounds on Reproductive Disease and Epigenetic Biomarkers of Ancestral Exposures. PLoS ONE. 2012, 7: e31901.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Nilsson EE, Schindler R, Savenkova MI, Skinner MK: Inhibitory actions of anti-Mullerian hormone (AMH) on ovarian primordial follicle assembly. PLoS ONE. 2011, 6: e20087.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Bruner-Tran KL, Osteen KG: Developmental exposure to TCDD reduces fertility and negatively affects pregnancy outcomes across multiple generations. Reprod Toxicol. 2011, 31: 344-350.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Waterland RA, Travisano M, Tahiliani KG, Rached MT, Mirza S: Methyl donor supplementation prevents transgenerational amplification of obesity. Int J Obes (Lond). 2008, 32: 1373-1379.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hauser MT, Aufsatz W, Jonak C, Luschnig C: Transgenerational epigenetic inheritance in plants. Biochim Biophys Acta. 1809, 2011: 459-468.Google Scholar
- Ruden DM, Lu X: Hsp90 affecting chromatin remodeling might explain transgenerational epigenetic inheritance in Drosophila. Curr Genomics. 2008, 9: 500-508.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Greer EL, Maures TJ, Ucar D, Hauswirth AG, Mancini E, Lim JP, Benayoun BA, Shi Y, Brunet A: Transgenerational epigenetic inheritance of longevity in Caenorhabditis elegans. Nature. 2011, 479: 365-371.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Pembrey ME: Male-line transgenerational responses in humans. Hum Fertil (Camb). 2010, 13: 268-271.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Guimaraes RM, Asmus CI, Meyer A: DDT reintroduction for malaria control: the cost-benefit debate for public health. Cad Saude Publica. 2007, 23: 2835-2844.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Sadasivaiah S, Tozan Y, Breman JG: Dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT) for indoor residual spraying in Africa: how can it be used for malaria control?. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2007, 77: 249-263.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Davies K: Strategies for eliminating and reducing persistent bioaccumulative toxic substances: common approaches, emerging trends, and level of success. J Environ Health. 2006, 69: 9-15.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Enayati A, Hemingway J: Malaria management: past, present, and future. Annu Rev Entomol. 2010, 55: 569-591.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- van den Berg H: Global status of DDT and its alternatives for use in vector control to prevent disease. Environ Health Perspect. 2009, 117: 1656-1663.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Aneck-Hahn NH, Schulenburg GW, Bornman MS, Farias P, de Jager C: Impaired semen quality associated with environmental DDT exposure in young men living in a malaria area in the Limpopo Province, South Africa. J Androl. 2007, 28: 423-434.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hauser R, Singh NP, Chen Z, Pothier L, Altshul L: Lack of an association between environmental exposure to polychlorinated biphenyls and p, p’-DDE and DNA damage in human sperm measured using the neutral comet assay. Hum Reprod. 2003, 18: 2525-2533.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- ATSDR: Agency for Toxic Substances and Diseases Registry (ATSDR)/US Public Health Service, Toxicological Profile for 4,4′-DDT, 4,4′-DDE, 4, 4′-DDD (Update). 1994, Atlanta, GA: ATSDRGoogle Scholar
- Longnecker MP, Klebanoff MA, Zhou H, Brock JW: Association between maternal serum concentration of the DDT metabolite DDE and preterm and small-for-gestational-age babies at birth. Lancet. 2001, 358: 110-114.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Jaga K, Brosius D: Pesticide exposure: human cancers on the horizon. Rev Environ Health. 1999, 14: 39-50.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Hamlin HJ, Guillette LJ: Birth defects in wildlife: the role of environmental contaminants as inducers of reproductive and developmental dysfunction. Syst Biol Reprod Med. 2010, 56: 113-121.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Eskenazi B, Chevrier J, Rosas LG, Anderson HA, Bornman MS, Bouwman H, Chen A, Cohn BA, de Jager C, Henshel DS, Leipzig F, Leipzig JS, Lorenz EC, Snedeker SM, Stapleton D: The Pine River statement: human health consequences of DDT use. Environ Health Perspect. 2009, 117: 1359-1367.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Valvi D, Mendez MA, Martinez D, Grimalt JO, Torrent M, Sunyer J, Vrijheid M: Prenatal concentrations of polychlorinated biphenyls, DDE, and DDT and overweight in children: a prospective birth cohort study. Environ Health Perspect. 2012, 120: 451-457.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- McAllister EJ, Dhurandhar NV, Keith SW, Aronne LJ, Barger J, Baskin M, Benca RM, Biggio J, Boggiano MM, Eisenmann JC, Elobeid M, Fontaine KR, Gluckman P, Hanlon EC, Katzmarzyk P, Pietrobelli A, Redden DT, Ruden DM, Wang C, Waterland RA, Wright SM, Allison DB: Ten putative contributors to the obesity epidemic. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2009, 49: 868-913.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Caballero B: The global epidemic of obesity: an overview. Epidemiol Rev. 2007, 29: 1-5.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Trasande L, Attina TM, Blustein J: Association between urinary bisphenol A concentration and obesity prevalence in children and adolescents. JAMA. 2012, 308: 1113-1121.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Manikkam M, Tracey R, Guerrero-Bosagna C, Skinner M: Plastics derived endocrine disruptors (BPA, DEHP and DBP) Induce epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of adult-onset disease and sperm epimutations. PLoS ONE. 2013, 8: e55387.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Tracey R, Manikkam M, Guerrero-Bosagna C, Skinner M: Hydrocarbon (Jet Fuel JP-8) induces epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of adult-onset disease and sperm epimutations. Reprod Toxicol. 2013, 36: 104-116.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Janesick A, Blumberg B: Obesogens, stem cells and the developmental programming of obesity. Int J Androl. 2012, 35: 437-448.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Sabin MA, Werther GA, Kiess W: Genetics of obesity and overgrowth syndromes. Best Pract Res Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2011, 25: 207-220.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Phan-Hug F, Beckmann JS, Jacquemont S: Genetic testing in patients with obesity. Best Pract Res Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2012, 26: 133-143.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Waterland RA: Is epigenetics an important link between early life events and adult disease?. Horm Res. 2009, 71: 13-16.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Anderson PJ, Critchley JA, Chan JC, Cockram CS, Lee ZS, Thomas GN, Tomlinson B: Factor analysis of the metabolic syndrome: obesity vs insulin resistance as the central abnormality. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 2001, 25: 1782-1788.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ferrannini E, Haffner SM, Mitchell BD, Stern MP: Hyperinsulinaemia: the key feature of a cardiovascular and metabolic syndrome. Diabetologia. 1991, 34: 416-422.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Franks S: Polycystic ovary syndrome. N Engl J Med. 1995, 333: 853-861.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Lauenborg J, Mathiesen E, Hansen T, Glumer C, Jorgensen T, Borch-Johnsen K, Hornnes P, Pedersen O, Damm P: The prevalence of the metabolic syndrome in a Danish population of women with previous gestational diabetes mellitus is three-fold higher than in the general population. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2005, 90: 4004-4010.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Chen SH, He F, Zhou HL, Wu HR, Xia C, Li YM: Relationship between nonalcoholic fatty liver disease and metabolic syndrome. J Dig Dis. 2011, 12: 125-130.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Akahoshi T, Uematsu A, Akashiba T, Nagaoka K, Kiyofuji K, Kawahara S, Hattori T, Kaneita Y, Yoshizawa T, Takahashi N, Uchiyama M, Hashimoto S: Obstructive sleep apnoea is associated with risk factors comprising the metabolic syndrome. Respirology. 2010, 15: 1122-1126.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mathew AV, Okada S, Sharma K: Obesity related kidney disease. Curr Diabetes Rev. 2011, 7: 41-49.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Kasturi SS, Tannir J, Brannigan RE: The metabolic syndrome and male infertility. J Androl. 2008, 29: 251-259.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rahmanpour H, Jamal L, Mousavinasab SN, Esmailzadeh A, Azarkhish K: Association between polycystic ovarian syndrome, overweight, and metabolic syndrome in adolescents. J Pediatr Adolesc Gynecol. 2012, 25: 208-212.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Motta AB: The role of obesity in the development of polycystic ovary syndrome. Curr Pharm Des. 2012, 18: 2482-2491.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Beard J: DDT and human health. Sci Total Environ. 2006, 355: 78-89.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nilsson EE, Anway MD, Stanfield J, Skinner MK: Transgenerational epigenetic effects of the endocrine disruptor vinclozolin on pregnancies and female adult onset disease. Reproduction. 2008, 135: 713-721.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Xie F, Zhang R, Yang C, Xu Y, Wang N, Sun L, Liu J, Wei R, Ai J: Long-term neuropeptide Y administration in the periphery induces abnormal baroreflex sensitivity and obesity in rats. Cell Physiol Biochem. 2012, 29: 111-120.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Phillips LK, Prins JB: The link between abdominal obesity and the metabolic syndrome. Curr Hypertens Rep. 2008, 10: 156-164.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- National Task Force on the Prevention and Treatment of Obesity: Overweight, obesity, and health risk. Arch Intern Med. 2000, 160: 898-904.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Anway MD, Skinner MK: Transgenerational effects of the endocrine disruptor vinclozolin on the prostate transcriptome and adult onset disease. Prostate. 2008, 68: 517-529.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Taylor JA, Richter CA, Ruhlen RL, vom Saal FS: Estrogenic environmental chemicals and drugs: mechanisms for effects on the developing male urogenital system. J Steroid Biochem Mol Biol. 2011, 127: 83-95.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Meredith S, Dudenhoeffer G, Jackson K: Classification of small type B/C follicles as primordial follicles in mature rats. J Reprod Fertil. 2000, 119: 43-48.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Tateno H, Kimura Y, Yanagimachi R: Sonication per se is not as deleterious to sperm chromosomes as previously inferred. Biol Reprod. 2000, 63: 341-346.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ward WS, Kimura Y, Yanagimachi R: An intact sperm nuclear matrix may be necessary for the mouse paternal genome to participate in embryonic development. Biol Reprod. 1999, 60: 702-706.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Guerrero-Bosagna C, Settles M, Lucker B, Skinner M: Epigenetic transgenerational actions of vinclozolin on promoter regions of the sperm epigenome. PLoS ONE. 2010, 5: e13100.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Guillette LJ, Gross TS, Masson GR, Matter JM, Percival HF, Woodward AR: Developmental abnormalities of the gonad and abnormal sex hormone concentrations in juvenile alligators from contaminated and control lakes in Florida. Environ Health Perspect. 1994, 102: 680-688.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Crews D, Gillette R, Scarpino SV, Manikkam M, Savenkova MI, Skinner MK: Epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of altered stress responses. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2012, 109: 9143-9148.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Nilsson E, Larsen G, Manikkam M, Guerrero-Bosagna C, Savenkova M, Skinner M: Environmentally induced epigenetic transgenerational inheritance of ovarian disease. PLoS ONE. 2012, 7: e36129.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- McGrowder DA, Jackson LA, Crawford TV: Prostate cancer and metabolic syndrome: is there a link?. Asian Pac J Cancer Prev. 2012, 13: 1-13.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Nelson RA, Bremer AA: Insulin resistance and metabolic syndrome in the pediatric population. Metab Syndr Relat Disord. 2010, 8: 1-14.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Rose DP, Haffner SM, Baillargeon J: Adiposity, the metabolic syndrome, and breast cancer in African-American and white American women. Endocr Rev. 2007, 28: 763-777.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Wisse BE: The inflammatory syndrome: the role of adipose tissue cytokines in metabolic disorders linked to obesity. J Am Soc Nephrol. 2004, 15: 2792-2800.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Cao J, Rebuli ME, Rogers J, Todd KL, Leyrer SM, Ferguson SA, Patisaul HB: Prenatal bisphenol a exposure alters sex-specific estrogen receptor expression in the neonatal rat hypothalamus and amygdala. Toxicol Sci. 2013, 133: 157-173.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- McMillen IC, Rattanatray L, Duffield JA, Morrison JL, MacLaughlin SM, Gentili S, Muhlhausler BS: The early origins of later obesity: pathways and mechanisms. Adv Exp Med Biol. 2009, 646: 71-81.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Massiera F, Barbry P, Guesnet P, Joly A, Luquet S, Moreilhon-Brest C, Mohsen-Kanson T, Amri EZ, Ailhaud G: A Western-like fat diet is sufficient to induce a gradual enhancement in fat mass over generations. J Lipid Res. 2010, 51: 2352-2361.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Dunn GA, Bale TL: Maternal high-fat diet effects on third-generation female body size via the paternal lineage. Endocrinology. 2011, 152: 2228-2236.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Gambineri A, Pelusi C, Vicennati V, Pagotto U, Pasquali R: Obesity and the polycystic ovary syndrome. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 2002, 26: 883-896.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Martinez-Bermejo E, Luque-Ramirez M, Escobar-Morreale HF: Obesity and the polycystic ovary syndrome. Minerva Endocrinol. 2007, 32: 129-140.PubMedGoogle Scholar
- Doyle TJ, Bowman JL, Windell VL, McLean DJ, Kim KH: Transgenerational effects of di-(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate on testicular germ cell associations and spermatogonial stem cells in mice. Biol Reprod. 2013, 88: 112.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Maric-Bilkan C: Obesity and diabetic kidney disease. Med Clin North Am. 2013, 97: 59-74.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Mlambo SS, van Vuren JH, Barnhoorn IE, Bornman MS: Histopathological changes in the reproductive system (ovaries and testes) of Oreochromis mossambicus following exposure to DDT. Environ Toxicol Pharmacol. 2009, 28: 133-139.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Cohn BA, Cirillo PM, Christianson RE: Prenatal DDT exposure and testicular cancer: a nested case–control study. Arch Environ Occup Health. 2010, 65: 127-134.View ArticlePubMedPubMed CentralGoogle Scholar
- Hart R, Hickey M, Franks S: Definitions, prevalence and symptoms of polycystic ovaries and polycystic ovary syndrome. Best Pract Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol. 2004, 18: 671-683.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Ozucelik DN, Karcioglu O, Topacoglu H, Fowler JR: Toxicity following unintentional DDT ingestion. J Toxicol Clin Toxicol. 2004, 42: 299-303.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- Carson R: Silent Spring. 1963, Houghton Mifflin: GreenburgGoogle Scholar
- Rogan WJ, Chen A: Health risks and benefits of bis(4-chlorophenyl)-1,1,1-trichloroethane (DDT). Lancet. 2005, 366: 763-773.View ArticlePubMedGoogle Scholar
- The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1741-7015/11/228/prepub
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.