Paper | Number of children/ informants | Informant | Nature of child-based outcome measure(s) | Significance (P<0.05) of improvement with intervention versu control |
---|---|---|---|---|
Bodenmann et al. [32] | 150 | Father | ECBI | Not significant (Intensity and Problem subscales) |
Connell et al. [50] | 23 | Father | ECBI | Significant benefit (Intensity and Problem subscales) |
 |  | Father | PDRC - Parent diary record checklist | Not significant |
Hahlweg et al. [51] | 43 | Father | Child Behavior Checklist--Parent Report (CBCL 1½-5, German version) | Not significant |
 |  | Father | SDQ | Not significant |
Hahlweg et al. [13] | 198 | Father | CBCL | Not significant |
 | 273 | Observers | Revised Family Observation Schedule (FOS-RIII). | Not significant |
 | 177 | Teachers | Caregiver Teacher Report Form (C-TRF 1.5 - 5) | Not significant |
Hoath & Sanders [53] | 21 | Teachers | Sutter-Eyberg Student Behavior Inventory-Revised (SESBI-R) | Not significant |
 |  | Teachers | Child Attention Problems Rating Scale (CAP) | Not significant |
Markie-Dadds & Sanders [56] | Â | Father | ECBI | Not significant |
 |  | Father | Parent Daily Report | Not significant |
Morawska & Sanders [62] | 75 | Teacher | Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire | Not significant apart from hyperactivity subscale |
McTaggart & Sanders [21] | Â | Teacher | Sutter-Eyberg Student Behavior Inventory (SESBI) | Not significant (except when baseline adjustment used) |
Morawska & Sanders [61] | 73 | Father | ECBI | Not significant |
 |  | Observers | Family observation schedule | Not significant |
Nicholson & Sanders [28] | 42 | Self report | Child Depression Inventory | Not significant |
 |  | Self report | Child Manifest Anxiety Scale | Not significant |
 |  | Self report | Coopersmith Self-Esteem Inventory | Not significant |
Plant & Sanders [64] | 74 | Independent observers | Revised Family Observation Schedule (FOS-RIII). | Significant benefit on negative behavior subscales (other subscales not reported) |
Prinz et al. [5] | Approximately 170,000 | Child Protective Services | Numbers of substantiated child maltreatment cases | Significant benefita |
 |  | Foster Care System | Out of home placements | Significant benefita |
 |  | Hospitals | Hospital visits for maltreatment | Significant benefita |
 |  | Child Protective Services | Maltreatment investigation | Not significant |
Roberts et al. [33] | 23 | Father | Total behavior problem subscale score of Developmental Behavior Checklist Parent Version. | Not significant |
 | 32 | Observer | FOS-IIIR noncompliance - targeted | Not significant |
 |  | Observer | FOS-IIIR noncompliance - general | Significant benefit |
 |  | Observer | FOS-IIIR Oppositional Behavior - targeted | Significant benefit |
 |  | Observer | FOS-IIIR Oppositional Behavior - general | Not significant |
 |  | Observer | FOS-IIIR Appropriate Behavior - targeted | Not significant |
 |  | Observer | FOS-IIIR Appropriate Behavior - General | Not significant |
Sanders et al. [65] | 255 | Father | ECBI | Significant benefit |
 |  | Father | Parent Daily Report | Significant benefit |
 |  | Observer | Revised Family Observation Schedule (FOS-RIII). Composite score for negative child behavior | Not significant |
Stallman & Ralph [25] | 36 | Teenagers | Conflict behavior questionnaire | Not significant |
Turner & Sanders [68] | 25 | Independent observers | Family Observation Schedule (disruptive behaviors) | Not significant |
Turner et al. [29] | 21 | Father | Child behavior checklist | Not significant |
 |  | Observer | Mealtime observation | Not significant |
 |  | Observer | Anthropometric measures | Not significant |