Study name | Study characteristics | Quality assessment | |||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Tx | Country | Diag | Outcome | No. sessions | Type of data | FU (weeks) | Total N | Rand. | AC | ITT | % attrition (Intv) | % attrition (Ctl) |
Barrett 2001 [67] | PST | USA | Dep - minor or dys | HDRS < 7 | 6 | D | 11 | 161 | WC | WC | Y | 18 | 16 |
Boot 1994 [58] | COU | UK | Mixed Anx and Dep | GHQ | 6 | C | 6 | 192 | AA | U | N | 46 | 40 |
Brodaty 1983 [66] | PP | AUS | Mixed Anx and Dep | GHQ | 8 | C | 8 | 78 | AA | U | N | 65 | 26 |
Catalan 1991 [68] | PST | UK | Mixed Anx and Dep | PSE | 4 | C | 11 | 47 | AA | U | N | 0 | 0 |
Dowrick 2000 [69] | PST | EU | Dep - MDD or dys | BDI | 6 | C | 26 | 317 | AA | WC | Y | 23 | 26 |
Earll 1982 [46] | CBT | UK | Mixed Anx and Dep | DSSI/sAD * | 7.7 | D | 32 | 50 | AA | U | N | 16** | |
Friedli 1997 [59] | COU | UK | Mixed Anx and Dep | BDI | 9 | C | 12 | 136 | AA | AA | Y | 16 | 23 |
Harvey 1998 [60] | COU | UK | Mixed Anx and Dep | HADS | 6 | C | 16 | 162 | AA | U | Y | 31 | 25 |
Hemmings 1997 [61] | COU | UK | Mixed Anx and Dep | MHSI | 5.7 | C | 16 | 188 | AA | U | N | 16 | 23 |
Holden 1989 [62] | COU | UK | Dep - MDD | RDC | 8 | D | 12 | 50 | AA | U | N | 0 | 0 |
Kendrick 2005 [70] | PST | UK | Mixed Anx and Dep | CIS-R | 6 | C | 26 | 168 | WC | WC | Y | 20 †| 31†|
Lang 2006 [71] | PST | USA | Mixed Anx and Dep | BSI-D | 4 | C | 12 | 62 | AA | U | Y | 34 | 17 |
Lindsay 1987 [47] | CBT | UK | Anx - GAD | GHQ-28 | 8 | C | 4 | 20 | AA | U | N | 0 | 0 |
Liu 2007 [72] | PST | TA | Mixed Anx and Dep | CIS-R | 2.27 | C | 16 | 169 | WC | AA | Y | 25 | 22 |
Lynch 1997 [73] | PST | USA | Dep - minor | HDRS | 6 | C | 7 | 29 | AA | U | N | 27 | 7 |
Lynch 2004 [74] | PST | USA | Dep - minor | HDRS | 6 | C | 6 | 36 | AA | U | N | 50 | 28 |
Marks 1985 [48] | CBT | UK | Anx - phobic | PS | 6 | C | 26 | 92 | AA | U | N | 37 | 20 |
Mynors-Wallis 1995 [75] | PST | UK | Dep - MDD | HDRS | 6 | C | 12 | 55 | AA | U | Y | 0 | 0 |
Mynors-Wallis 1997 [76] | PST | UK | Mixed Anx and Dep | CIS | 4.5 | C | 26 | 70 | AA | AA | N | 20 | 13 |
Power 1989 [49] | CBT | UK | Anx - GAD | HAM-A | 4 | C | 6 | 21 | AA | U | Y | 0 | 0 |
Power 1990 [51] | CBT | UK | Anx - GAD | CGI = 1 | 7 | D | 10 | 79 | AA | U | N | 0 | 0 |
Power 2000 [50] | CBT | UK | Anx - panic | HAM-A | 6 | C | 12 | 72 | AA | U | N | 16 | 17 |
Prendegast 2001 [52] | CBT | AUS | Dep - mixed | EPDS < 10 | 6 | D | 26 | 37 | AA | U | N | 0 | 0 |
Robson 1984 [53] | CBT | UK | Mixed Anx and Dep | PS | 3.7 | C | 14 | 429 | AA | U | N | 0 ††| 0 ††|
Schreuders 2007 [77] | PST | NL | Mixed Anx and Dep | HADS | 6 | C | 12 | 175 | AA | WC | N | 30 | 22 |
Scott 1992 [54] | CBT | UK | Dep - MDD | HDRS | 9.8 | C | 16 | 60 | AA | AA | Y | 3 | 3 |
Scott 1997 [55] | CBT | UK | Dep - MDD | HDRS | 6 | C | 7 | 48 | AA | U | N | 25 | 33 |
Sharp 1996 [56] | CBT | UK | Anx - panic | HAM-A ‡ | 7 | D | 13 | 154 | AA | U | Y | 21§ | 24§ |
Sharp 2004 [57] | CBT | UK | Anx - panic | HAM-A | 8 | C | 12 | 59 | AA | U | Y | 16 | 14 |
Simpson 2003 [63] | COU | UK | Dep - mixed | BDI | 5 | C | 26 | 145 | AA | U | Y | 11 | 10 |
Van Schaik 2006 [65] | IPT | NL | Dep - MDD | MADRS | 8 | C | 26 | 143 | WC | WC | Y | 16 | 16 |
Ward 2000 [27] | CBT | UK | Dep - mixed | BDI | 5 | C | 16 | 197 | AA | U | Y | 11 | 8 |
 | COU |  |  |  | 6.4 |  |  |  |  |  |  | 8 |  |
Wickberg 1996 [64] | COU | SW | Dep - mixed | MADRS ¶ | 6 | D | 7 | 45 | AA | U | N | 0 | 0 |
Williams 2000 [78] | PST | USA | Dep - minor or dys | HDRS < 7 | 6 | D | 11 | 278 | WC | AA | Y | 18§ | 15§ |