Skip to main content

Table 6 Overview of extracted descriptive study data for the discipline Psychology

From: Best practice for motor imagery: a systematic literature review on motor imagery training elements in five different disciplines

Reference

First author

Year

Country

Language

Study duration, days

Intervention duration, days

Study design

Study groups

Number of participants

Participants

Gender

Age, years

Body part

Training task

Focus

Measurement events

Results

Study rating

                 

Relative change

Absolute change

 

[132]

Allami, N

2008

FR

E

1

1

RCT

5

25

Students

NSt

Mean = 29, range 20 to 37

Upper limb

Grasping task

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

7/10

[133]

Alves, J

1999

PT

E

28

28

CCT

4

64

Pupils

Both

Range 15 to 17

Whole body

Volleyball service

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

3/10

[134]

Andre, C

1986

USA

E

5

5

CCT

3

66

Students

Male

Mean = 21 ± 3

Whole body

Frisbee disc gold putting/throwing

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

4/10

[135]

Chevalier, H

1986

CA/FR

E

1

1

RCT

5

30

Students

Both

Undergraduate students

Upper limb

Moving computer mouse

C

1 (post-test only)

↗

↗

6/10

[136]

Clark, LV

1960

USA

E

28

21

CCT

2

144

Pupils

Male

High-school pupils

Whole body

Pacific coast one-hand foul shot

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

5/10

[137]

Clegg, BC

2004

USA

E

1

1

SCRD

N/A

28

Older adults, students

Both

Old: mean = 74, range 62 to 88; young: mean = 22, range 18 to 26

Upper limb

Movement with stylus

M

1 (post-test only)

N/A

→

8/11

[138]

Corbin, CB

1967

USA

E

28

21

RCT

3

30

Pupils

Male

High-school pupils

Whole body

Wand-juggling skill

M

2× BL, post-test, FU 1 day

↘

↗

5/10

[139]

Cornwall, MW

1991

USA

E

4

4

RCT

2

24

Females

Female

Mean = 23, range 21 to 25

Lower limb

Strength of quadriceps muscle

S

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

6/10

[140]

Decety, J

1991

USA

E

1

1

RCT

2

20

Students

Both

Mean = 23 ± 2

Lower limb

Walking on beam

M

5 (during int., post-test)

↗

↗

6/10

[41]

Etnier, J

1996

USA

E

1

1

RCT

9

153

Students

Both

Mean ± SD = 23 ± 4

Whole body

Basketball shooting

M

3 (pre-test, during int., post-test)

↗

↗

6/10

[141]

Gassner, K

2007

DE

G

999

21

RCT

2

36

Students

Both

Mean = 24

Lower limb

Walking with knee prosthesis

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

7/10

[142]

Gordon, S

1994

AU

E

21

21

RCT

3

64

High-school pupils

NSt

High-school pupils

Whole body

Cricket outswing

M

6 (pre-test, during int., post-test)

→

↗

6/10

[143]

Gray, SW

1990

USA

E

21

14.0

RCT

2

24

Males

Male

Mean = 22, range 18 to 26

Whole body

Forehand and backhand racquetball skills

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

6/10

[144]

Hellwing, W

1976

DE

G

14

14

CCT

2

72

Pupils

Male

Mean = 12, range 11 to 13

Whole body

Fosbury flop

M

1 (post-test)

→

↗

4/10

[145]

Hemayattalab, R

2009

IR

E

38

24

RCT

5

40

Mentally retarded children

NSt

Mean = 14, range 12 to 15

Whole body

Basketball free throw

M

3 (pre-post-test, FU)

↗

↗

6/10

[146]

Herrero, J

2004

ES

E

7

7

CCT

2

27

Students

Female

Mean ± SD = 20 ± 0.1

Upper limb

Bench-press

S

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

6/10

[56]

Isaac, AR

1992

NZ

E

126

126

CCT

2

70

Students

NSt

NSt

Whole body

Three trampoline skills

M

6 (after 1, 6, 7, 12, 13, 18 weeks)

→

→

6/10

[147]

Jaehme, W

1978

DE

G

21

14

RCT

3

48

Pupils

Male

Mean = 16

Whole body

Crawl swimming

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

5/10

[42]

Jarus, T

2000

IL

E

1

1

RCT

2

89

Children, adults

Both

Children: mean ± SD = 10 ± 1; adults: 28 ± 5; older adults: 67 ± 2

Upper limb

Two-arm coordination task

C

6 (during int., FU)

↗

↗

6/10

[148]

Jones, JG

1965

AU

E

14

14

RCT

2

71

Students

Male

Students

Whole body

Hock-swing upstart

M

2 (during int., post-test)

↗

↗

7/10

[149]

Kelsey, IB

1961

CA

E

22

2

RCT

3

36

Students

Male

University students

Trunk, lower limb

Endurance abdominal + thigh-flexor muscles

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

7/10

[150]

Kohl, RM

1980

USA

E

1

1

RCT

3

60

Students

NSt

Mean = 21

Upper limb

Pursuit rotor task

C

28 (during int., post-test)

→

↗

5/10

[150]

Kohl, RM

1980

USA

E

1

1

RCT

3

60

Students

Male

Mean = 20

Upper limb

Pursuit rotor task

C

36 (during int., post-test)

→

↗

5/10

[150]

Kohl, RM

1980

USA

E

1

1

RCT

6

108

Pupils

Male

Mean = 17

Upper limb

Pursuit rotor task

C

NSt

↘

↗

5/10

[151]

Kornspan, AS

2004

USA

E

5

4

RCT

4

40

Students

Both

Mean = 20

Whole body

Golf putting

M

3 (pre-post-tes)t

→

↗

6/10

[152]

Kremer, P

2009

AU

E

1

1

RCT

4

209

Students

Both

Mean ± SD = 21 ± 3

Whole body

Dart throwing with non-preferred hand

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

7/10

[153]

Krigolson, O

2006

CA

E

1

1

CCT

6

42

Healthy participants

NSt

Range 18 to 32

Lower limb

Walking along walkway

M

20 (during int., post-test)

→

↗

4/10

[57]

Lejeune, M

1994

BE

E

7

4

CCT

4

40

University students + staff

Both

Mean = 22, range 19 to 27

Whole body

Counterattack forehand and backhand (table tennis)

M

3 (Pre-post-test, FU)

↗

↗

5/10

[154]

Linden, CA

1989

USA

E

14

8

RCT

2

23

Healthy participants

Female

Mean = 79, range 67 to 90

Whole body

Walking balance, equilibrium reactions

M

3 (pre-test, during int., post-test)

→

→

8/10

[45]

Lutz, R

2001

USA

E

1

1

RCT

5

120

Students

Both

Undergraduate students

Whole body

Golf putting

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

7/10

[155]

Maring, JR

1990

USA

E

1

1

RCT

2

26

University students + staff

Both

Mean = 30; range 22 to 40

Upper limb

Tossing a ping-pong ball to target

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

6/10

[67]

Martin, KA

1995

CA

E

6

6

RCT

3

39

Students

Both

Mean ± SD = 27 ± 6

Whole body

Golf putting

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

6/10

[156]

McAleney, P

1990

USA

E

999

21

RCT

2

20

Students

Both

Mean = 19, range 18 to 20

Whole body

Tennis shooting skills

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

7/10

[157]

Minas, SC

1978

UK

E

1

1

RCT

4

32

Students

Both

Undergraduate students

Whole body

Throwing performance

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

6/10

[68]

O, J

2008

CA

E

999

1

RCT

5

97

Healthy students

Both

Mean ± SD = 18 ± 2

Whole body

Dribbling a soccer ball

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

7/10

[158]

Papaxanthis, PC

2002

FR

E

1

1

RCT

2

16

Students

Both

Mean = 21, range 19 to 23

Lower + upper limb

Walking + writing task

M

5 (during int., post-test)

→

↗

6/10

[159]

Phipps, SJ

1969

USA

E

21

21

RCT

2

72

Students

Male

University students

Whole body

Hock swing, jump-foot, soccer hitch kick

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

6/10

[160]

Ranganathan, VK

2004

USA

E

231

84

RCT

4

30

Healthy participants

Both

Mean ± SD = 30 ± 5

Upper limb

Muscle strength of little finger abduction, elbow flexion

S

18 (BL, during int., FU)

→

↗

6/10

[35]

Rapp, G

1973

DE

G

14

9

RCT

3

58

Pre-school children

Both

Mean = 6

Whole body

Skipping

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

7/10

[161]

Rawlings, E

1972

USA

E

11

10

RCT

3

24

Students

Female

Undergraduate students

Upper limb

Rotary pursuit tracking

C

10 (pre-test, during int., post-test)

→

↗

6/10

[161]

RawlingsE

1972

USA

E

10

9

RCT

2

20

Students

Male

Students

Upper limb

Rotary pursuit tracking

C

10 (pre-test, during int., post-test)

→

↗

5/10

[69]

Reiser, M

2005

DE

G

28

28

RCT

3

34

Students

Both

Mean ± SD = 24 ± 2, range 20 to 27

Upper limb

Bench-press

S

4 (pre-test, during int., post-test)

↘

↗

6/10

[83]

Rodrigues, EC

2010

BR

E

1

1

CS

N/A

18

Students

Both

Mean = 26, range 19 to 33

Lower limb

Plantar flexion

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

9/11

[162]

Ryan, E

1981

USA

E

1

1

RCT

3

39

Students

Male

Undergraduate students

Upper limb + whole body

'Dial-a-maze' pattern, stabilometer performance

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↘

↗

5/10

[163]

Ryan, E

1982

USA

E

1

1

RCT

6

80

Traffic officers

Male

Mean = 36, range 23 to 57

Whole body

Stabilometer performance

M

4 (pre-test, during int., post-test)

↗

↗

7/10

[164]

Shackell, EM

2007

CA

E

21

10

RCT

3

30

Students

Male

Mean ± SD = 20 ± 2

Lower limb

Strength-training of hip flexor muscle

S

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

7/10

[165]

Sidaway, B

2005

USA

E

28

28

RCT

3

24

Students

Both

Mean = 23, range 19 to 26

Lower limb

Ankle dorsiflexor torque

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

7/10

[166]

Singer, RN

1970

USA

E

35

28

RCT

5

65

Students

Female

College students

Upper limb

Learning a pursuit rotor task

C

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

5/10

[167]

Smith, LE

1962

USA

E

1

1

CCT

6

60

Students

Male

Mean = 20, range 17 to 27

Upper limb

Hand-eye coordination task; punchboard learning task

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

4/10

[72]

Smith, D

2001

UK

E

21

21

RCT

2

27

Students

Both

Mean ± SD = 20 ± 3

Whole body

Landing hockey penalty

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

7/10

[71]

Smith, D

2004

UK

E

49

49

RCT

3

19

University students + staff

Male

Mean ± SD = 30 ± 8

Upper limb

Strength of abductor digiti minimi

S

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

7/10

[71]

Smith, D

2004

UK

E

1

1

RCT

4

24

University students + staff

Both

Mean ± SD = 29 ± 8

Upper limb

Barrier knock-down task

C

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

7/10

[168]

Smyth, MM

1975

UK

E

1

1

RCT

7

70

Students

Both

Undergraduate and postgraduate students

Upper limb

Mirror drawing of a star

C

2 (pre-post-test)

↘

↗

5/10

[168]

Smyth, MM

1975

UK

E

1

1

RCT

7

71

Students

Both

Undergraduate and postgraduate students

Upper limb

Pursuit rotor task

C

1 (post-test)

↗

↗

5/10

[169]

Start, KB

1960

AU

E

9

9

CS

N/A

35

Pupils

Male

12

Whole body

Basketball throw

M

2 (pre-post-test)

N/A

↗

6/11

[170]

Start, KB

1964

AU

E

7

6

CS

N/A

21

Students

Male

Mean = 20, range 18 to 21

Whole body

Single leg upstart on high-bar

M

1 (post-test)

N/A

↗

7/11

[87]

Start, KB

1964

AU

E

7

6

CS

N/A

44

Students

Male

Mean = 19, range 18 to 25

Whole body

Single leg upstart on high-bar

M

1 (post-test)

N/A

→

7/11

[88]

Start, KB

1964

AU

E

14

6

CS

N/A

32

Students

Male

Mean = 20, range 18 to 21

Whole body

Single leg upstart on high-bar

M

1 (post-test)

N/A

→

6/11

[171]

Stebbins, RJ

1968

USA

E

42

21

RCT

5

93

Students

Male

College students

Whole body

Throwing ball into target

M

8-18 (pre-test, during int., post-test)

→

↗

5/10

[172]

Surburg, PR

1968

USA

E

63

56

CCT

7

183

Students

Male

Junior college students

Whole body

Tennis forehand drive

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

5/10

[36]

Taktek, K

2004

CA

E

1

1

CCT

4

64

Children

Both

Mean = 9, range 8 to 10

Upper limb

Pushing play vehicle

C

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

4/10

[73]

Toussaint, L

2010

FR

E

3

2

RCT

8

80

Students

Both

Mean ± SD = 23 ± 3

Lower limb

Knee joint angles

M

3 (pre-post-test, FU)

→

↗

6/10

[173]

Tunney, N

2006

USA

E

2

2

RCT

2

19

Older adults

Both

Mean = 76, range 66 to 89

Lower limb

Walking with quad cane + climbing four stairs

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

7/10

[174]

Twining, W

1949

USA

E

22

20

RCT

3

36

Students

Male

College students

Whole body

Throwing rings at target

M

2 (pre-post-test)

-1

↗

4/10

[175]

van Gyn, GH

1990

CA

E

42

42

RCT

4

40

Students

Both

Undergraduate students

Lower limb

Power + sprint performance on ergometer

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

6/10

[176]

Vandell, RA

1943

USA

E

20

18

RCT

3

36

Pupils and college students

Male

Junior, senior high-school and college students

Whole body

Throwing darts at target, basketball free throws

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

5/10

[37]

Vergeer, I

2006

UK

E

28

28

RCT

3

36

University staff

Both

Mean ± SD = 41 ± 10

Lower limb

Flexibility around hip joint

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

7/10

[74]

Wakefield, CJ

2009

UK

E

999

28

RCT

4

32

Students

Female

University students

Whole body

Netball shooting performance

C

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

7/10

[75]

White, KD

1979

AU

E

9

8

CCT

4

24

High-school pupils + university students

NSt

Mean = 19, range 13 to 27

Whole body

Action-reaction swimming start

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

4/10

[177]

Whiteley, G

1966

UK

E

84

84

CCT

4

88

Pupils

Male

Mean = 11

Whole body

Neck spring, head spring, short-arm overswing

M

1 (post-test)

↗

↗

3/10

[76]

Williams, JG

2004

UK

E

21

21

RCT

3

24

Undergraduate students

Both

Mean ± SD = 21 ± 2

Lower limb

Rom hip flexion

M

6 (pre-test, during int., post-test, FU)

↗

↗

7/10

[178]

Wohldamm, EL

2007

USA

E

84

2

CCT

4

80

Students

NSt

Undergraduate and postgraduate students

Upper limb

Number typing task

M

2 (post-test)

→

↗

4/10

[178]

Wohldamm, EL

2007

USA

E

1

1

CCT

4

108

Students

NSt

Undergraduate and postgraduate students

Upper limb

Number typing task

M

3 (pre-test, FU)

→

↗

5/10

[179]

Woolfolk, RL

1985

USA

E

1

1

RCT

6

48

Students

Male

Undergraduate college students

Whole body

Putt golf balls into cup

M

2 (pre-post-test)

→

↗

7/10

[180]

Woolfolk, RL

1985

USA

E

7

6

RCT

3

30

Students

Both

College students

Whole body

Golf backswing and putting stroke

M

2 (pre-post test)

↗

↗

5/10

[77]

Wright, CJ

2009

UK

E

999

42

RCT

5

50

Students

NSt

Mean ± SD = 21 ± 4

Upper limb

Biceps curl task

S

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

7/10

[78]

Yaguez, L

1998

DE

E

1

1

CCT

2

58

Volunteers

Both

Mean ± SD = 35 ± 11, range 22 to 73

Upper limb

Ideogram drawing

C

3 (pre-test, during int., post-test)

→

↗

6/10

[78]

Yaguez, L

1998

DE

G

1

1

CCT

2

52

Volunteers

Both

Mean = 30, range 22 to 49

Upper limb

Connecting circles

C

3 (pre-test, during int., post-test)

↗

↗

6/10

[181]

Zecker, SG

1982

USA

E

1

1

RCT

4

40

Students

Both

Undergraduate college students

Whole body

Tossing beanbag to target

M

2 (pre-post-test)

↗

↗

5/10