Skip to main content

Table 2 Quality assessment of medical certificates of cause of death pre- and post-training in the Philippines, Myanmar, and Sri Lanka (training of trainers strategy)

From: Improving medical certification of cause of death: effective strategies and approaches based on experiences from the Data for Health Initiative

Assessment

Philippines

Myanmar

Sri Lanka

MCCODs with errors (%)

MCCODs with errors (%)

MCCODs with errors (%)

Pre-training (N = 975)

Post-training (N = 959)

Percentage improvement*

Pre-training (N = 595)

Post-training (N = 600)

Percentage improvement*

Pre-training (N = 517)

Post-training (N = 558)

Percentage improvement*

Incorrectly completed certificates (at least one error)

72.9

43.6

40.1

99.8

74.8

33.4

95.4

68.5

28.2

 Certificates with one error

37.2

28.4

23.6

21.7

23.7

−9.2

25.9

32.3

−24.7

 Certificates with two or more errors

35.7

15.3

57.1

78.2

51.2

34.5

69.4

36.2

47.8

Certificates with at least one major error†

41.6

22.6

45.6

63.2

44.8

29.1

58.8

37.5

36.2

Certificates with minor errors only

31.3

21.1

32.5

36.6

30.0

18.0

36.6

31.0

15.3

Certificates with major errors

 Multiples causes per line

21.2

6.0

71.6

24.4

10.8

55.7

38.9

20.8

46.5

 Incorrect sequence of events leading to death

27.1

12.4

54.2

7.9

5.8

26.5

37.1

17.0

54.1

 Illegible handwriting

0.8

1.1

− 37.5

4.2

2.8

33.3

0.6

0.0

 

 Ill-defined condition entered as an underlying cause of death

28.6

15.5

45.8

44.5

32.7

26.5

4.4

10.6

140.9

 Additional information on external cause not available

4.8

1.2

75.0

–

–

–

–

–

–

 Additional information on neoplasms not available

2.3

1.9

17.0

1.4

0.3

78.5

4.3

0.5

95.0

Certificates with minor errors

 Presence of blank lines within the sequence of events

–

–

–

0.2

0.3

50.0

2.1

2.7

− 28.6

 Abbreviations used in certifying the death

7.1

0.8

88.7

50.8

31.0

38.9

36.0

20.3

43.6

 Absence of disease time interval

37.4

23.7

36.6

93.4

65.3

30.1

87.0

53.2

38.8

 Additional errors on the certificate

5.3

1.1

79.2

1.6

0.7

56.2

2.9

0.2

93.1

  1. Total column percentages may total > 100% as a single MCCOD may contain more than one error
  2. –No data available
  3. *Negative values indicate lower quality after training
  4. †Category may contain minor errors