Skip to main content

Table 4 Quality analysis of included articles

From: Allocation of intensive care resources during an infectious disease outbreak: a rapid review to inform practice

Author (year) Critical appraisal tool Criteria met, n/total (%) Overall appraisal (reason)
Adalja (2013) [77] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3)* Include
Adeniji and Cusack (2011) JBI-cohort 7/11 (63.6) Include
Ardagh (2006) [101] JBI-text & opinion 3/6 (50.0) Include
Ashton-Cleary (2011) [40] JBI-cross-sectional 6/8 (75.0) Include
Azoulay (2020) [44] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Barie (2020) [124] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3) Include
Brandao-Neto [125] JBI-cohort 7/11 (63.6)* Include
Challen (2007) JBI-cohort 8/11 (72.7) Include
Cheung (2012)-MJA [39] JBI-cohort 9/11 (81.8) Include
Cheung (2012)-Crit Care Resusc [48] JBI-cohort 9/11 (81.8) Include
Cheung (2017) [94, 95] JBI-cross-sectional 6/8 (75.0) Include
Christian (2006) [28] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3)* Include
Christian (2009) [79] JBI-cohort 8/11 (72.7) Include
Christian (2010) [85] Delphi process 5/11 (45.5) Include
Christian (2014) [11] Delphi process 10/11 (90.9) Include
Cinti (2009) [86] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Commons and Denholm (2012) [67] JBI-diagnostic test accuracy 5/10 (50.0) Include
Daugherty Biddison (2014)-CHEST [88] Delphi process 10/11 (90.9) Include
Daugherty Biddison (2014)-Annals ATS [87] JBI-qualitative
JBI-quasi-experimental
6/10 (60.0)
5/9 (55.6)*
Include
Daugherty Biddison (2018) [98] JBI-qualitative
JBI-quasi-experimental
8/10 (80.0)
5/9 (55.6)*
Include
Daugherty Biddison (2019) [58] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3)* Include
Devereaux (2008) [89] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3)* Include
Dries (2014) [96] Delphi process 10/11 (90.9) Include
Eastman (2010) [90] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Ehmann (2020) [31] JBI-text & opinion  6/6 (100)  Include
Einav (2014) [91] Delphi process 10/11 (90.9) Include
Emanuel [10] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3)* Include
Enfield (2011) [70] JBI-cohort 6/11 (54.5) Seek further info (conference abstract)
Estella (2012) [68] JBI-cohort 9/11 (81.8) Include
Farrell (2020) [81] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Frolic (2009) [36] AGREE Reporting Checklist 14/23 (60.9) Include
Grissom (2010) [72] JBI-cohort 9/11 (81.8) Include
Guest (2009) [78] JBI-cohort 7/11 (63.6) Include
Gupta (2020) [51] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3) Include
Han (2020) [35] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Herreros (2020) [45] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Hick (2006) [43] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3)* Include
Ibrahim (2020) [65] No critical appraisal for development of intelligence dashboard Not applicable Include
Janig (2020) [30] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Kanter (2015) [27] No critical appraisal for modeling data Not applicable Include
Kaposy (2010) [34] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3) Include
Khan (2009) [73] JBI-cohort 7/11 (63.6) Include
Leclerc (2020) [42] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Lin and Anderson-Shaw (2009) [23] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3)* Include
Marckmann (2020) [46] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Marriott (2012) [41] JBI-cohort 6/11 (54.5) Seek further info (conference abstract)
Miller (2010) [74] JBI-cohort 7/11 (63.6) Seek further info (conference abstract)
Montgomery (2020) [52] JBI-text & opinion 4/6 (66.7)*  Include
Morton (2014) [63] JBI-cohort 8/11 (72.7) Seek further info (conference abstract)
Morton (2015) [65] JBI-cohort 8/11 (72.7) Include
Muller (2010) [60] JBI-cohort 9/11 (81.8) Include
Murad (2009) [54] JBI-cross-sectional 4/8 (50.0) Include
Myles (2012) [57] JBI-case control 9/10 (90.0) Include
PCP Ethic Committee (2020) [47] JBI-text & opinion 3/6 (50.0) Include
Pereira (2012) [69] JBI-cohort 9/11 (81.8) Include
Powell (2008) [24] AGREE Reporting Checklist 12/23 (52.2) Include
Prekker (2020) [25] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3)* Include
Real de Asua (2020) [32] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3) Include
Rhodes (2020) [83] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3) Include
Rowan (2010) [55] JBI-cohort 8/11 (72.7) Include
Rubinson (2005) [92] JBI-text & opinion 4/6 (66.7)* Include
Ryan (2020) [66] JBI-cohort 7/11 (63.6) Include
Saleh (2016) [71] JBI-cohort 6/11 (54.5) Seek further info (conference abstract)
Seethala and Keller (2020) [82] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Shahpori (2011) [75] JBI-cohort 10/11 (90.9) Include
Shekar (2020) [102] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Silva (2012) [93] JBI-qualitative 8/10 (80.0) Include
Sprung (2010) [38] Delphi process 6/11 (54.5) Include
Sprung (2020) [33] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3) Include
Steinberg (2020) [84] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Swiss Academy of Medical Sciences & Swiss Society of Intensive Care (2020) [49] AGREE Reporting Checklist 12/23 (52.2) Include
Tabery and Mackett (2008) [99] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Talmor (2007) [62] JBI-cohort 10/11 (90.9) Include
Tambone (2020) [107] JBI-text & opinion 4/6 (66.7) Include
Tillyard (2010) [97] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3) Include
Utley (2011) [26] No critical appraisal for modeling data Not applicable Include
Valiani (2020) [29] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
Vergano (2020) [53] JBI-text & opinion 4/6 (66.7) Include
Vincent and Creteur (2020) [50] JBI-text & opinion 2/6 (33.3) Include
Warrillow (2020) [37] JBI-text & opinion 5/6 (83.3) Include
Wilkens and Klein (2010) [56] JBI-cross-sectional 4/8 (50.0) Include
Williams and Gannon (2009) [76] JBI-cohort 7/11 (63.6) Include
Winsor (2014) [103] JBI-text & opinion 6/6 (100) Include
  1. Abbreviations: JBI Joanna Briggs Institute
  2. *One or more items are “not applicable”