Skip to main content

Table 2 Contextual parameters and their uncertainty ranges

From: Quantifying the potential value of antigen-detection rapid diagnostic tests for COVID-19: a modelling analysis

Parameter

Value

References

 

Hospital setting

Community setting

 

Epidemiology

Prevalence of current or recent SARS-CoV-2 infection (%) *

25

5

Assumption

Proportion amongst those tested who are in acute phase

0.5–1.00

0.5–1.00

Assumption

Of those in acute phase, number of infectious days remaining (days)

5–15

5–15

[16]

Case fatality rate amongst hospitalised COVID-19 patients

0.20–0.30

N/A

[7]

Case fatality reduction amongst COVID-19 patients on dexamethasone (1—risk ratio)

0.07–0.25

N/A

[7]

NAT performance

 

NAT sensitivity (for current or recent SARS-CoV-2)

0.85–0.95

0.85–0.95

[17,18,19,20,21,22,23]

NAT specificity

0.99–1

0.99–1

[17,18,19,20]

NAT availability (proportion able to access NAT test)

0.1–1

0.1–1

Assumption

Cost per NAT test ($)

20–70

20–70

 

NAT turnaround time (days)

1–10

5–15

[10], Expert consultation

Confirm Ag-RDT negative results with NAT

Y/N

Y/N

 

Confirm Ag-RDT positive results with NAT **

Y/N

Y/N

 

Isolate and initiate treatment (if indicated) whilst awaiting NAT result

Y

N

 

Ag-RDT performance (assumed fixed)

 

Ag-RDT sensitivity for current infection, relative to NAT (%, assumed only amongst acute cases)*

0.80

0.80

[14, 15]

Ag-RDT specificity, relative to NAT (%)*

0.98

0.98

[14, 15]

Cost per Ag-RDT test ($)

5

5

[14]

Clinical judgement and management

 

Sensitivity of clinical judgement in absence of NAT

0.45–0.99

0.45–0.99

[24,25,26,27]

Specificity of clinical judgement in absence of NAT

0.20–0.70

0.20–0.50

[24,25,26,27]

Proportion of hospitalised patients with a negative COVID-19 test result (true and false negatives) that are initiated onto dexamethasone

0.05–0.15

N/A

Assumption

Duration of isolation (days)

10

10

[16]

Duration of dexamethasone treatment (days)

10

N/A

[7]

Cost of isolation per day ($)

50–350

N/A

[28,29,30]

Cost of dexamethasone per day ($)

0.13–3.5

N/A

[31]

  1. Ranges define limits on uniform distributions, chosen to capture plausible parameter ranges that may apply across a variety of low- and middle-income settings. As described in the main text, the main analysis is a systematic uncertainty analysis, structured to identify which of these uniform distributions is most influential for model outcomes. *We performed sensitivity analyses on these fixed parameters, with results presented in the supporting information. We varied prevalence in the hospital setting between 10 and 30% and in the community setting between 1 and 10% (Additional file 7: Fig.S4). We varied Ag-RDT sensitivity and specificity between 75-95% and 98–100%, respectively, relative to NAT (Additional file 8: Fig.S5). **We exclude any parameter draws involving NAT confirmation of both Ag-RDT negative and Ag-RDT positive results.