Skip to main content

Table 2 Survival outcomes by three combinations of two parameters: ctDNA status change from baseline to postoperative timepoints, postoperative ctDNA status and whether ACT was conducted or not, and ctDNA status change before and after ACT

From: Prognostic value of circulating tumor DNA in operable non-small cell lung cancer: a systematic review and reconstructed individual patient-data based meta-analysis

Subgroup

HR

LCI

UCI

P value

HR

LCI

UCI

P value

HR

LCI

UCI

P value

DFS by ctDNA status changes from baseline to postoperative timepoints

 Neg-Neg

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Neg-Pos

4.59

2.37

8.87

 < 0.001

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Pos-Neg

2.79

2.02

3.87

 < 0.001

0.60

0.31

1.16

0.126

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Pos-Pos

9.01

6.41

12.72

 < 0.001

1.92

0.98

3.75

0.058

3.16

2.22

4.50

 < 0.001

DFS by postoperative ctDNA status and ACT

 Neg_ACT

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Neg_nonACT

0.54

0.39

0.74

 < 0.001

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Pos_ACT

3.16

2.17

4.60

 < 0.001

5.70

3.83

8.50

 < 0.001

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Pos_nonACT

4.79

3.31

6.94

 < 0.001

8.69

5.89

12.83

 < 0.001

1.50

0.97

2.32

0.067

DFS by postoperative ctDNA status and ACT for stage II/III NSCLC

 Neg_ACT

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Neg_nonACT

0.76

0.40

1.45

0.401

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Pos_ACT

2.96

1.85

4.76

 < 0.001

3.62

1.76

7.48

 < 0.001

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Pos_nonACT

6.59

4.02

10.80

 < 0.001

7.99

3.83

16.68

 < 0.001

2.21

1.23

3.95

0.008

DFS by ctDNA status changes before and after ACT

 Neg-Neg

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Neg-Pos

4.46

1.75

11.35

0.002

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Pos-Neg

2.06

0.80

5.27

0.132

0.45

0.16

1.30

0.452

1.00 (ref.)

 

 Pos-Pos

5.49

2.35

12.80

 < 0.001

1.21

0.46

3.22

0.701

2.67

1.01

7.02

0.047

  1. ACT (with) adjuvant chemotherapy, HR hazard ratio, LCI lower 95% confidential interval, nonACT without adjuvant chemotherapy, NSCLC non-small cell lung cancer, DFS disease-free survival, Pos ctDNA positive, Neg ctDNA negative, UCI upper 95% confidential interval