Control of tuberculosis in large cities in developed countries: an organizational problem
BMC Medicine volume 9, Article number: 127 (2011)
Tuberculosis (TB) is still a serious public health issue, even in large cities in developed countries. Control of this old disease is based on complicated programs that require completion of long treatments and contact tracing. In an accompanying research article published in BMC Public Health, Bothamley and colleagues found that areas with a ratio lower than one nurse per forty notifications had increased rates with respect to TB notifications, smear-positive cases, loss to follow-up and treatment abandonment across the UK. Furthermore, in these areas there was less opportunity for directly observed therapy, assistance with complex needs, educational outreach and new-entrant screening. In this commentary, we discuss the importance of improving organizational aspects and evaluating TB control programs. According to Bothamley and colleagues, a ratio of one nurse per forty notifications is an effective method of reducing the high TB incidences observed in London and in other cities in developed countries, or to maintain the decline in incidence in cities with lower incidences. It is crucial to evaluate TB programs every year to detect gaps early.
See related article: http://www.biomedcentral.com/1471-2458/11/896
Tuberculosis (TB) is a contagious bacterial disease that can be fatal without treatment, and any delay in diagnosis of pulmonary and laryngeal cases increases the chances of transmission. The incidence of TB is greater in large cities than in non-urban areas or in the country as a whole, as Bothamley and colleagues describe in their article published this month in BMC Public Health . The authors also found that cities that did not achieve the target of one nurse per forty TB notifications had worse TB control indicators than cities reaching this target. The authors concluded that control depends on adequate numbers of specialist TB nurses for early detection and case holding. They also observed strikingly high incidences in 2009 in cities such as Manchester (59.1/100, 000) and London (44.4/100, 000) in relation to other English cities. In other western European cities, in general, the incidences were also lower [2, 3] (Figure 1). These data led to London appearing widely in the media as 'the European capital of TB'  following publication of a paper in The Lancet with the subtitle 'London has one of the highest rates of TB in Western Europe, and the city homeless population are most at risk and the hardest to treat' .
TB affects the most vulnerable populations, including HIV-infected people, drug abusers, the homeless and immigrants, in a disproportionate way. These populations mostly live in urban settings and, as such, influence TB epidemiology in large developed cities [6, 7]. TB control programs have to adapt to any new challenge, and new control strategies should be implemented when a new problem arises . New York City, for instance, had to deal with a serious epidemiological situation when the AIDS epidemic broke out. From 1978 to 1992, the number of patients with TB nearly tripled due to HIV infection, drug resistances and the abandonment of TB programs, but fortunately they were able to apply comprehensive control measures (including directly observed therapy (DOT) and control of nosocomial transmission) and the situation reversed . The peak of incidence was observed in 1992 (3, 811 cases, incidence of 52.0/100, 000), declining to 10.8/100, 000 (895 cases) in 2008 . TB was considered a political priority and the New York TB program received substantial funds; DOT was the rule with a high number of DOT workers. The use of incentives for patients dually infected with TB and HIV (the equivalent of $100/month for adherent patients) or a $25 'show-up voucher' to inmates to encourage them to continue their TB treatment after release from prison, along with other measures to elevate the status of DOT workers and recognize them as the true heroes of modern public health, contributed to the effectiveness of the program .
With the financial crisis, the New York model is difficult to replicate in most cities due to its high cost and TB programs should include new control strategies based on improvements in health organization. Solid public health organization, combined with precise knowledge of local healthcare and the social system, along with the co-operation of hospitals and specialized clinics, could help to better implement specific control strategies.
Unfortunately, in many cities it is very difficult to create or maintain a team of nurses dedicated solely to TB due to relatively low TB incidence and also because of limited resources dedicated to this disease. For example in Barcelona, the TB Program has had, from its inception in 1987, public health nurses (PHN) who carry out follow-up with patients and perform contact tracing but are also in charge of other communicable diseases. The program also involves active surveillance of cases (reporting of cases is promoted, microbiological results and hospital discharges are monitored, and the link between AIDS and TB registers is also monitored). In the first few years, we observed the influence on TB epidemiology of injecting drug users (IDU) and persons with HIV infection, and incidence increased until it peaked in 1992 (1, 096 cases, 67/100, 000) . DOT was added early for those patients with predictors of poor adherence (homeless, IDU, prisoners). The inclusion of DOT in methadone programs and tight coordination between the TB programs in the prisons and the city was very useful in achieving a high level of treatment completion among IDU . Following the increase use of DOT and the use of antiretroviral treatments, TB incidence decreased, but with the massive immigration observed from 2000 onwards, this decline has been attenuated (Figure 2). Consequently, since 2003 we have incorporated community health workers (CHW) to help PHN in follow-up and contact tracing. These CHW also visit the patient at home, at the hospital, at the DOT facility and act as translators and cultural mediators .
The link between surveillance, control and operational research has always been a priority, and has facilitated coordination among all health workers involved in TB control (clinicians, microbiologists, epidemiologists, social services managers). In the last few years, TB care services have been reorganized due to massive immigration and to concentrate the contact tracing in five TB Units. All large hospitals in the city have TB clinical units that carry out diagnosis, treatment, monitoring of the patient and contact tracing in the household contacts. The TB case manager nurse in these clinical units is the key professional in this reorganization. Figure 3 outlines the organization of TB care in Barcelona. The city is divided into four health areas and in each area there is an integrated TB working committee which is representative of all health workers involved in TB control. The TB Program team includes a physician, 12 PHN for about 500 cases a year (ratio 1/35-45) and 6 CHW. Both PHN and CHW are also in charge of other notifiable diseases (TB represents about 40% of the total workload). Close coordination with the Unit Clinic case manager nurse allows the management of cases. The CHW time contribution is presently based on immigrant TB patient characteristics (number of cases and country of origin).
It is important to evaluate TB programs every year in order to identify gaps in services, data monitoring, and so on. The audit of TB services against elements contained in the national TB Action Plan (Table 5 of the accompanying paper) is a very good example as it can detect which criterion needs to be improved in each city. The epidemiological evaluation of a TB program should be based on few indicators in order to facilitate annual evaluations (decline in TB incidence, diagnostic delay, completion of TB treatment, coverage of contact tracing, TB meningitis in children under 4 years) .
Over the next few years, with a probable decline in TB incidence, it may be difficult to maintain big teams of specialized TB nurses within the public health structures. Should this prove to be the case, the challenge of containing TB in hard-to-reach groups would be daunting and diagnostic delay would be likely to increase in a context of low-incidence and low-resource settings with the possibility of epidemic outbreaks among affected children . The recommendations of Bothamley and colleagues in relation to TB nurses, along with those of scientific societies published since 1988 , could be helpful in maintaining these resources because a ratio of specialized TB nurses to patients is established. In large cities, maintaining the TB program in a Public Health structure that also performs surveillance and control of other notifiable diseases and epidemic outbreaks could be crucial in achieving long-term resource and management expertise.
The current economic crisis will have long-term impacts on communicable disease control and it is critical to keep the public health budget  at an adequate level, although TB programs can increase their efficiency by improving their organizational structures. To take advantage of other resources for transmissible diseases, such as the resources for HIV prevention and for control of epidemic outbreaks, co-operation with other programs (including Immigration and IDU services) will be essential. Brigs stated in 1914 that 'Public health is purchasable; a community can determine its own death rate' . Following these ideas, Reichman strongly recommends fostering and maintaining the political will that allows enhancement of public health programs that can move towards the elimination of TB . Each city needs to define its needs according to its particular epidemiological situation, but the ratio of one nurse per forty TB cases, as suggested by Bothamley and colleagues, is a very good starting point.
AO and JAC are working in the Barcelona TB programs and each year organize an International TB Workshop. AO coordinates the PHN and CHW programe, analyzes the TB data base and writes an annual report.
JAC coordinates the Barcelona TB Investigation Unit and is the principal investigator at site 31 of the CDC TB Trials Consortium and of TB Research at the Spanish Society of Pneumology (SEPAR).
directly observed therapy
public health nurses
community health workers
injecting drug users.
Bothamley GH, Kruijshaar ME, Kunst H, Woltmann G, Cotton M, Saralaya D, et al: Tuberculosis in UK cities: workload and effectiveness of TB control programmes. BMC Public Health. 2011, 11: 896-10.1186/1471-2458-11-896.
Tuberculosis has re-emerged in European cities as a major public health problem. [http://metropolitantb.org]
Registre Belge de la tuberculose 2009. FARES asbl, fébrier. 2011, [http://www.fares.be]
Adams S: London 'the TB capital of Europe'. [http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthnews/8206887/London-the-TB-capital-of-Europe.html]
Burki T: Tackling tuberculosis in London's homeless population. Lancet. 2010, 376: 2055-2056. 10.1016/S0140-6736(10)62282-9.
Kamran K, Rea E, McDermaid C, Stuart R, Chambers C, Wang J, Chan A, Gardam M, Jamieson F, Yang J, Hwang SW: Active tuberculosis among homeless persons, Toronto, Ontario, Canada, 1998-2007. Emerg Inf Dis. 2011, 17: 357-65.
Hollo V, Amato-Gauci A, Ködmön C, Manissero D: Tuberculosis in the EU and EEA/EFTA countries - what is the latest data telling us?. Euro Surveill. 2009, 14: pii = 19151, [http://www.eurosurveillance.org/ViewArticle.aspx?ArticleId=19151]
de Vries G, Van Hest RA, Richardus JH: Impact of mobile radiographic screening on TB among drug users and homeless persons. Am J Crit Care Med. 2007, 176: 201-207. 10.1164/rccm.200612-1877OC.
Frieden TR, Fujiwara PI, Washko RM, Hamburg MA: Tuberculosis in New York City--turning the tide. N Eng J Med. 1995, 333: 229-33. 10.1056/NEJM199507273330406.
New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene: Annual Summary 2008: New York City is Stopping TB. New York, NY. 2009, [http://www.nyc.gov/html/doh/downloads/pdf/tb/tb_annualsummary08.pdf]
Fujiwara PI, Larkin C, Frieden TR: Directly observed therapy in New York City. History, implementation, results and chalenges. Clin Chest Med. 1997, 18: 135-148. 10.1016/S0272-5231(05)70363-4.
Rodrigo T, Caylà JA, Galdós-Tangüis H, García de Olalla P, Brugal MT, Jansà JM: Proposing indicators for evaluation of tuberculosis control programmess in large cities based on the experience of Barcelona. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis. 2001, 5: 432-440.
Marco A, Caylà JA, Serra M, Pedro R, Sanrama C, Guerrero R, Ribot N: Predictors of adherence to tuberculosis treatment in a supervised therapy programmes for prisoners before and after release. Study Group of Adherence to Tuberculosis Treatment of Prisoners. Eur Respir J. 1998, 4: 967-971.
Ospina JE, Orcau A, Millet JP, Caylà JA, Casals M, Rius C, Sanchez F: Effectiveness of community health workers for the control of tuberculosis. Proceedinds of the 40th World Conference on Lung Health of the IUATL. Int J Tubec Lung Dis. 2009, 13 (suppl 1).
Gillman A, Berggren I, Bergström SE, Wahlgren H, Bennet R: Primary tuberculosis infection in 35 children at a Swedish day care center. Pediatr Infect Dis J. 2008, 27: 1078-1082. 10.1097/INF.0b013e31817e83f4.
Joint Tuberculosis Committee of the British Thoracic Society: Control and prevention of tuberculosis in the United Kingdom: Code of Practice 2000. Thorax. 2000, 55: 887-901. 10.1136/thorax.55.11.887.
Suhrcke M, Stuckler D, Suk JE, Desai M, Senek M, McKee M, Tsolova S, Basu S, Abubakar I, Hunter P, Rechel B, Semenza JC: The impact of economic crises on communicable disease transmission and control: a systematic review of the evidence. PLoS One. 2011, 6: e20724-10.1371/journal.pone.0020724. Epub 2011
Our motto. Health News. Monthly Bulletin, New York State Dept of Health, February 1914, 30:table of contents
Reichman LB: Defending the Public's Health Against Tuberculosis. JAMA. 1997, 278: 865-867.
The pre-publication history for this paper can be accessed here:http://www.biomedcentral.com/1741-7015/9/127/prepub
Acknowledgements and funding
To the all health workers involved in the Barcelona TB Program in their 25th year (1986-2011).
The authors acknowledge partial support for this research from the CIBER Epidemiología y Salud Pública (CIBERESP), Spain.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Both authors contributed equally to the production of the manuscript and also read and approved the final manuscript.
About this article
Cite this article
Caylà, J.A., Orcau, A. Control of tuberculosis in large cities in developed countries: an organizational problem. BMC Med 9, 127 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1186/1741-7015-9-127