Comprehensive metabolic profiling of chronic low-grade inflammation among generally healthy individuals
BMC Medicine volume 15, Article number: 210 (2017)
Inflammation occurs as an immediate protective response of the immune system to a harmful stimulus, whether locally confined or systemic. In contrast, a persisting, i.e., chronic, inflammatory state, even at a low-grade, is a well-known risk factor in the development of common diseases like diabetes or atherosclerosis. In clinical practice, laboratory markers like high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (hsCRP), white blood cell count (WBC), and fibrinogen, are used to reveal inflammatory processes. In order to gain a deeper insight regarding inflammation-related changes in metabolism, the present study assessed the metabolic patterns associated with alterations in inflammatory markers.
Based on mass spectrometry and nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy we determined a comprehensive panel of 613 plasma and 587 urine metabolites among 925 apparently healthy individuals. Associations between inflammatory markers, namely hsCRP, WBC, and fibrinogen, and metabolite levels were tested by linear regression analyses controlling for common confounders. Additionally, we tested for a discriminative signature of an advanced inflammatory state using random forest analysis.
HsCRP, WBC, and fibrinogen were significantly associated with 71, 20, and 19 plasma and 22, 3, and 16 urine metabolites, respectively. Identified metabolites were related to the bradykinin system, involved in oxidative stress (e.g., glutamine or pipecolate) or linked to the urea cycle (e.g., ornithine or citrulline). In particular, urine 3’-sialyllactose was found as a novel metabolite related to inflammation. Prediction of an advanced inflammatory state based solely on 10 metabolites was well feasible (median AUC: 0.83).
Comprehensive metabolic profiling confirmed the far-reaching impact of inflammatory processes on human metabolism. The identified metabolites included not only those already described as immune-modulatory but also completely novel patterns. Moreover, the observed alterations provide molecular links to inflammation-associated diseases like diabetes or cardiovascular disorders.
Inflammation is a corporeal response to damaging stimuli associated with the activation of various molecular mechanisms. In addition to localized inflammatory reactions at the site of injury (redness, swelling, overheating, pain and disturbed function of the affected tissue or organ), reactions of the entire organism can be affected, depending on the severity of inflammation . Both the local and systemic responses initiated by an inflammatory process indicate an imbalance in metabolism in the tissues affected. The metabolic disequilibrium at the site of injury is caused by the increased immune cell number (cells of the immune system flow through the increased blood flow to the injury site) and the diverse metabolic requirements of immune cells, which differ from those of local cells . In addition to a general feeling of illness, there are a number of different inflammatory parameters that are of clinical importance, including high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (hsCRP), white blood cell count (WBC), and fibrinogen. Localized and systemic inflammatory reactions with changes in the classical inflammatory parameters are indications of the altered metabolism in the affected tissue . After remission of the inflammatory response, tissue metabolism normalizes. If the remission process is interrupted, for example, due to persistence of pathogens, toxins, or other stimuli, damage of healthy tissue could occur. With respect to metabolic disease (e.g., diabetes), damage might be induced due to the adverse effect of over nutrition as the derived lipid species are able to induce the inflammatory response, i.e., induction of cytokine release, in resistant macrophages located in adipose tissue . In general, chronic inflammation is considered integral to the development of serious systemic diseases such as type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM), cardiovascular diseases, gastrointestinal disorders, and rheumatoid arthritis.
CRP and fibrinogen are acute phase proteins  that are secreted from the liver upon interleukin 6 (IL-6) stimulation; IL-6 is released by activated macrophages and T cells. The primary role of CRP is binding to phospholipid species of damaged cells or pathogens to initiate the complement system. As the cause of tissue damage could be from various sources, elevations in hsCRP reflect a general inflammatory response rather than being attributed to a specific cause . Another routinely measured indicator of systemic inflammation in particular is WBC . Studies have shown elevated WBC levels not only during infection , but also in relation to cardiovascular diseases , T2DM , or metabolic syndrome . Thus, all three inflammatory markers – hsCRP, fibrinogen, and WBC – are clinically useful in the diagnosis and follow-up of diseases.
Considering the close link of (chronic) inflammation with common diseases and its burden on the patient and the health system, improving the understanding about the metabolic implications of low-grade chronic inflammatory processes is an urgent need. A suitable tool for this purpose is metabolic profiling, as it allows the investigation of a broad range of small molecules (metabolites) in various body fluids. Consequently, the analysis of these metabolites in relation to inflammatory markers such as hsCRP, WBC, or fibrinogen enables the identification of alterations at the molecular level and thereby characterizes the (subclinical) inflammatory state. Previous studies have identified metabolites such as fatty acids, like arachidonic acid or palmitate, various lysophosphatidylcholines (lysoPC) (18:1 and 18:2), metabolites of purine metabolism, and amino acids associated with inflammatory processes in patients suffering from obesity , T2DM [12, 13], and their complications [14, 15].
To gain a deeper insight into inflammation-related metabolism, the present study combined non-targeted, i.e., based on liquid-chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS), and targeted, i.e., based on high-performance LC-MS/MS and 1H-NMR spectroscopy, metabolomics approaches. Through an investigation of metabolic patterns associated with alterations in hsCRP, WBC, and fibrinogen levels in humans in both plasma and urine, we are the first to generate a compilation of metabolites spanning multiple pathways, thus providing a link between metabolism and inflammation in a large non-diabetic sample of the general population.
The Study of Health in Pomerania (SHIP-TREND) is a population-based study located in West Pomerania, a rural region in north-east Germany . A stratified (age, sex, and city/country of residence), random sample of 8826 adults aged 20–79 years was drawn from population registries. Sample selection was facilitated by centralization of local population registries in the Federal State of Mecklenburg, West Pomerania. Baseline examinations were conducted between 2008 and 2012. In total, 4420 subjects chose to participate (50.1% response). All participants gave written informed consent before taking part in the study. The study was approved by the ethics committee of the University of Greifswald and conformed to the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki. SHIP data are publicly available for scientific and quality control purposes. Data usage can be applied for via www.community-medicine.de.
Plasma and urine metabolomics data based on MS and NMR were available for a subsample of up to 1000 subjects without diabetes (self-reported). To address the aims of the present study we had to exclude subjects with missing values in inflammatory markers or confounding factors (n = 47), as well as those with acute inflammation defined as hsCRP > 10 mg/L (n = 28). In total, the present study comprised 925 subjects (Additional file 1: Figure S1).
Laboratory measurements and phenotypic characterization
Smoking status (current, former or never smokers), daily alcohol consumption, and physical activity (≥1 h training a week) were assessed using computer-aided personal interviews. Waist circumference was measured to the nearest 0.1 cm using an inelastic tape midway between the lower rib margin and the iliac crest in the horizontal plane.
Fasting blood samples were taken from the cubital vein of participants in the supine position between 7.00 a.m. and 12.00 p.m. Over the same time span, spot urine samples were taken. Except for hsCRP and cystatin C, all clinical assays were performed using fresh plasma/serum samples. To this end, blood samples were immediately placed on ice. On average, 50 minutes elapsed between blood collection and measurement. Further, serum, EDTA-plasma, and urine samples were immediately partitioned into multiple aliquots and stored in a centralized biobank at –80 °C. Out of the frozen samples, metabolomics and hsCRP measurements were performed after completion of the study with an average storage time of 4.25 years. Fibrinogen concentrations were determined in citrate plasma samples according to Clauss, using a BCS-XP system (Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics, Eschborn, Germany). WBC concentration was determined in EDTA whole blood samples using the Sysmex XT 2000, XE 5000, or SE9000 analyzers (Sysmex, Kobe, Japan) or the Advia 2120i (Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics). Three levels of control material were measured by skilled technical personnel. Glucose, triglyceride, alanine aminotransferase, and hsCRP concentrations were measured using the Dimension Vista 500 analytical system (Dimension VISTA, Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics). Serum cystatin C concentrations were measured using a nephelometric assay (Dimension VISTA, Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics) with a functional sensitivity of 0.05 mg/L. Cystatin C-based estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) was calculated using the CKD-EPI cystatin C equation: eGFR = 133 × min(serum cystatin C/0.8, 1)-0.499 × max(serum cystatin C/0.8, 1)-1.328 × 0.996age [×0.932 if female] .
A detailed description of all applied measurement techniques is provided in the Supplemental information. The following passage briefly summarizes the most important steps.
Metabolomics measurements based on MS
Non-targeted metabolomics analysis for metabolic profiling was conducted at the Genome Analysis Center, Helmholtz Zentrum München, Germany. Briefly, two separate LC-MS/MS analytical methods were used as previously published  to obtain broad metabolite spectra in plasma and urine samples in a non-targeted manner. After pre-processing, 475 plasma and 558 urine metabolites remained for the statistical analyses. Note that 177 plasma metabolites and 302 urine metabolites could not be unambiguously assigned to a chemical identity and are referred to hereafter with the notation “X” followed by a unique number.
Targeted metabolomics profiling of the plasma samples was performed using the AbsoluteIDQ p180 Kit (BIOCRATES LifeSciences AG, Innsbruck, Austria, online supplementary methods) and was conducted at the Institute of Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine, Universtiy Medicine Greifswald, Germany. This approach allows simultaneous absolute quantification of 188 metabolites using a combination of liquid chromatography (Agilent 1260 Infinity Binary LC, Santa Clara, United States) and mass spectrometry (AB SCIEX 5500 QTrap™ mass spectrometer; AB SCIEX, Darmstadt, Germany). After normalization and pre-processing of the data, 183 metabolites were available for subsequent analysis.
Metabolomics measurements based on 1H-NMR
Urine samples were measured on a Bruker DRX-400 NMR Spectrometer (Bruker BioSpin GmbH, Rheinstetten, Germany) operating at a 1H frequency of 400.13 MHz following a published workflow . The Fourier-transformed and baseline-corrected NMR spectra were manually annotated by spectral pattern matching using Chenomx NMR Suite 6.1 (Chenomx Inc., Edmonton, Alberta, Canada) to deduce absolute urinary concentrations of 51 metabolites.
Most of the metabolites were unique to one of the applied techniques. However, 44 and 22 metabolites in plasma and urine, respectively, were overlapping with at least one other technique. With respect to plasma, following the grouping of metabolites in biochemical classes (i.e., lipids, amino acids and carbohydrates), correlations of those metabolites measured on both platforms were computed with all members of the same biochemical class. Subsequently, the metabolite with the higher median correlation across all class members was kept for further analysis. Regarding the lower sensitivity of NMR compared to MS, in cases of duplicated measures, those obtained on the MS were kept for further analyses. In total, 613 plasma and 587 urine metabolites were used in the subsequent statistical analyses.
Continuous data are expressed as median (25th–75th quartile) and nominal data are expressed as percentage. For bivariate analyses, the Mann–Whitney U-test (continuous data) or χ2 test (nominal data) were used to compare women and men. Linear regression models were performed to assess the association between inflammatory markers, namely, hsCRP, WBC, and fibrinogen (independent), and plasma and urine metabolites (dependent). Concentrations of all metabolites as well as hsCRP levels were log-transformed to fulfil the requirements of linear regression. Models were adjusted for age, sex, waist circumference, smoking behavior and physical activity. To avoid spurious results in linear regression analysis, univariate outliers for each metabolite were excluded whenever concentrations exceeded more than three standard deviations from the mean value. Sensitivity analyses on the influence of latent diabetic subjects (n = 29; meeting one of the following criteria: (1) fasting glucose > 11.1 nmol/L, or (2) HbA1c > 6.5%, or (3) intake of diabetic medication (ATC code A10)) was performed by exclusion of those subjects. To account for multiple testing, we adjusted the P values from regression analyses by controlling the false discovery rate (FDR) at 5% using the Benjamini–Hochberg procedure.
Classification analyses were performed to prove the discriminative ability of the metabolome as well as to highlight central metabolites. As no established cut-offs for low-grade inflammation exist we defined an advanced inflammatory state using the population distributions of the inflammatory markers, i.e., participants with hsCRP, WBC, and fibrinogen levels, by denoting all of those in the upper quartile as having an advanced inflammatory state. In contrast, a healthy state was defined as being consistently in the lower quartile of inflammatory markers. As a result, 42 and 54 subjects presented with low or high inflammatory conditions, respectively. For classification purposes, a random forest was applied embedded in a two-stage cross-validation procedure (Additional file 1: Figure S2). The random forest was implemented in R via the randomForest package (v 4.6-10) . This combination allowed for variable selection and validation of a defined subset (limited to 10 metabolites), even in the absence of an independent test set. Further, evaluation of multiple permutations among training, testing, and validation sets allowed us (1) to achieve a reliable estimate of the discriminative performance of the metabolome and (2) to judge the consistency of the named markers to discriminate an inflammatory state. For this purpose, 872 metabolites with less than 20% missing values were chosen along with participant age, sex, waist circumference, and eGFR as additional variables. Missing values were imputed using the k-nearest neighbor technique as implemented in the R package impute, setting k to 10.
Statistical analyses were performed using SAS version 9.4 (SAS statistical software, version 9.4, SAS Institute, Inc., NC, USA) and R 3.1.1 (R Foundation for statistical computing, version 3.1.1, Vienna, Austria).
The general characteristics of the study population are provided in Table 1. Men and women were 50 years old on average. Men were less often never smokers, had a higher waist circumference, and exhibited higher levels of glucose, triglycerides, and eGFR, whereas cholesterol levels were slightly lower compared to those of women. With respect to inflammatory markers, no differences were detected for WBC, whereas fibrinogen and hsCRP were lower in men than in women.
Associations with inflammatory markers in the plasma metabolome
HsCRP, WBC, and fibrinogen showed significant associations with 71, 20, and 19 out of 613 plasma metabolites, respectively; none was common to all traits (Fig. 1, Additional file 2: Table S1). Bradykinin metabolites, biliverdin, gamma-glutamylmethionine, the sphingomyelin C24:1, the amino acids glutamine, glycine and serine, and some compounds with unknown chemical identity were shared by at least two of the assessed traits. A wealth of unique associations with hsCRP became apparent, including positive associations with intermediates of branched-chain amino acid and lysine degradation (e.g., valine or pipecolate (Figs. 1 and 2)), acylcarnitines, long-chain fatty acids, further sphingomyelins, and diacylphosphatidylcholines, as well as cortisol levels (Fig. 2). Significant inverse associations with hsCRP became apparent with respect to members of the urea cycle and several lysophosphatidylcholines (lysoPC) containing (poly)unsaturated fatty acids (e.g., lysoPC 18:1 and 18:2; Fig. 2). The most prominent findings unique to WBC were the positive associations with lactate, pyruvate, sphingosine, and hexadecanedioate. Unique associations with fibrinogen were observed for plasma levels of pregnanediol-3-glucuronide (positively) and phosphatidylcholines with fatty acid residues bound to one acyl and one alkyl group (inversely).
Associations with inflammatory markers in the urine metabolome
In general, associations with urinary metabolites were less frequent compared with plasma metabolites (Fig. 1 and Additional file 2: Table S2); HsCRP, WBC, and fibrinogen showed significant associations with 22, 3, and 16 out of 587 urine metabolites, respectively (Fig. 1). A positive association with the disaccharide 3’-sialyllactose was common to all investigated traits; further, it was the strongest association within the present study (Fig. 1 and Additional file 2: Table S2). The related metabolite N-acetylneuraminate (sialic acid) was positively associated with hsCRP and fibrinogen similarly to C-mannosyltryptophan (Fig. 2) and the unknown X-14302. Similar to plasma, hsCRP comprised most of the unique associations (Fig. 1), including homocitrulline, taurocholate sulfate and several unknown compounds (positively) as well as glycine, 2-aminooctanoate, glycylproline, and 7-methylguanine (inversely). Unique associations with fibrinogen consisted of 3-ureidopropionate, hexanoylglycine, 5-alpha-pregnan-3-beta,20-alpha-diol disulfate, o-cresol sulfate, and the xenobiotics 3-ethylphenylsulfate and cotinine N-oxide.
The vast majority of the presented results remained stable after exclusion of 29 latent diabetic subjects (Additional file 1: Figure S3). Single departures might be most likely due to random variation as comparison between the false discovery rate values of the whole and the subpopulation revealed no gross effects (Additional file 1: Figure S3).
Predicting an advanced inflammatory state
In addition to association testing, we searched for a discriminative signature between healthy participants (only low inflammatory markers) and an advanced inflammatory state, defined as the consistent presence of inflammatory markers in the highest quartile among the present cohort (n = 54). To this end, we applied a random forest analysis embedded in a two-stage cross-validation procedure combining variable selection with model evaluation. We achieved moderately robust classification as shown by a median area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of 0.83 across 20 validation runs using a subset of 10 metabolites (Fig. 3). The approach clearly highlights the importance of five metabolites, consisting of three plasma metabolites, lysoPC 18:2, adenosine 5’-phosphate, and glutamate, as well as two urine metabolites, C-mannosyltryptophan and 3’-sialyllactose.
Chronic low-grade inflammation as reflected by elevations in blood parameters, such as hsCRP, WBC, or fibrinogen, is accompanied by a multitude of metabolic changes. In an attempt to comprehensively characterize such changes, the present study used a state-of-the-art metabolomics approach comprising non-targeted and targeted techniques in an apparently healthy sample of the general population. The absence of acute inflammatory processes as well as diabetic cases allowed the profiling of subclinical molecular patterns. This profiling provided novel insights in altered pathways possibly contributing to the adverse effect of inflammatory processes on metabolic and cardiovascular diseases. Urinary metabolites in particular might be promising biomarkers to ease the diagnosis and monitoring of inflammation-associated diseases.
The bradykinin systems as proof of principle
One common feature of hsCRP and fibrinogen indicating low-grade inflammation was the increased appearance of bradykinin metabolites in plasma. Bradykinin, as part of the kinin-kallikrein system, is released from high-molecular-weight kininogen upon interaction with kallikrein, which in turn is activated by factor XIIa in the course of activated coagulation . Once released, bradykinin acts as a vasoactive peptide hormone via binding to bradykinin receptors, B1 and B2, in the vascular endothelium and induces the classical symptoms of inflammation, i.e., swelling and redness . However, increasing vascular permeability and enhancement of smooth muscle tone are only two of several mechanisms of bradykinin action . Bradykinin plays a particularly important role in various classifications of angioedema, but also in other inflammatory processes such as allergic rhinitis . Conflicting reports exist about its relation with the cardiovascular system. Moreover, bradykinin production leads to the release of various cytokines , e.g., IL-6, which further activates the innate immune system and, thereby, CRP release from the liver. In this respect, our findings mirror previously described biological pathways emphasizing the validity of the presented approach.
Metabolites linked to an oxidative stress signature
The strongest associations with respect to amino acids were demonstrated for plasma levels of glutamine (negatively) and pipecolate (positively) (Fig. 2). Pipecolate, a metabolite in the degradation of the essential amino acid lysine, has shown antioxidative properties in a number of cell and animal models . A possible explanation for its association with hsCRP might be an increased demand of antioxidant agents during inflammation in tissues highly active in respiration. One opportunity to compensate the increased energy demand accompanied by inflammatory processes would be an increased utilization of fat from deposits, such as white adipose tissue. Indeed, within the present study, an increase in hsCRP was associated with increased plasma levels of free fatty acids. After uptake in respiratory active tissues, free fatty acids are subjected to oxidation within the mitochondria. To pass the outer mitochondrial membrane, the fatty acids have to be conjugated with carnitine, yielding acylcarnitines. In situations of pronounced lipolysis and respiration, these intermediates are likely to be spilled into the circulation, which is further supported by our observations. A possible mediator in this context might be the elevated cortisol concentrations observed in the present study. Cortisol is well-known to counteract a prolonged inflammatory milieu by diminishing the production of pro-inflammatory mediators, including IL-12, IFN-γ, or TNF-α, at the transcriptional level. Importantly, the interrelation between cortisol and cytokines is mutual. An acute injection of cytokines led to a rise in cortisol levels, seen as an adaptive response to fulfil the increased energy demand of inflamed tissues . Consistently, an experimental study in healthy volunteers  showed a cortisol-dependent induction of lipolysis from femoral and abdominal adipose tissue.
It should be noted that even microbiota are able to produce pipecolate  when given lysine as a substrate, and host dysbiosis is a hallmark of many inflammatory diseases [28, 29]. As a direct link between plasma pipecolate levels and composition of the gut microbiota has not been available up to now, further studies are needed to investigate this possible line of explanation in more detail.
In contrast to the positive association with pipecolate, we observed a significant inverse association of hsCRP with glutamine and to a lesser extent with WBC. The non-essential amino acid glutamine attenuated inflammatory signs when given as a supplement in clinical applications for patient recovery after abdominal surgery  and in the perioperative period [31, 32], as well as in patients who needed intensive care. In addition to the lowering of inflammatory markers, e.g., hsCRP, TNF-α, or IL-6, even surrogates of intestinal permeability were reduced . The authors concluded that glutamine is able to effectively reduce inflammation. This finding is in concordance with the inverse association between hsCRP and glutamine in the present study. It is known that glutamine, as a precursor of glutathione, plays a crucial role in the prevention of oxidative damage in the human body  and thus also has a positive influence on the maintenance of the gastrointestinal barrier  and the endothelial function of the blood vessels . An intervention study among women of advanced age showed that a 6-month administration of amino acids, including glutamine, significantly reduced hsCRP and thus has potential beneficial effects .
Inverse association between inflammation and members of the urea cycle
In addition to its role as precursor of glutathione, glutamine is implicated in arginine metabolism. Arginine is an amino acid of the urea cycle  and was inversely associated with hsCRP in the present study. Previous investigations have suggested an immune-modulating effect  and anti-inflammatory properties  of arginine. Alterations in the urea cycle with respect to hsCRP were further highlighted by inverse associations with the plasma metabolites ornithine and citrulline as well as a strong association with urinary homocitrulline. The latter is detected in large quantities in urine in cases of urea cycle disorders . These findings might be a general feature of (severe) inflammatory conditions, as a previous study observed decreased levels of urea cycle intermediates in subjects with sepsis and trauma . Interestingly, during the recovery phase and in the reduction of inflammation, a rise in arginine and citrulline levels were observed. Furthermore, among critically ill patients, low plasma citrulline levels were related to low levels of arginine and glutamine as well as elevated hsCRP levels . Even if the underlying mechanisms are not yet understood in detail, it can be assumed that glutamine, with its central position in metabolism, plays a crucial role in inflammation. However, longitudinal studies are needed to assess the possible anti-inflammatory effect of high baseline glutamine concentrations.
Phospholipids as potential inflammatory mediators
A very prominent molecular signature associated with hsCRP consisted of lysoglycerophospholipds with choline (lysoPC), inositol, or ethanolamine as the head-group and unsaturated fatty acids as residues merely in an inverse manner. Lysoglycerophospholipds are derived from hydrolysis of phospholipids and this might point towards diminished phospholipase A1 or A2 activity. In contrast to our findings, several lines of evidence suggest increased phospholipase activity under inflammatory conditions [41,42,43]. A diminished production could therefore be reasonable, as one of the primary precursors of lysoPC, glycerophosphorylcholine, also decreased with increasing hsCRP levels. LysoPCs have often been discussed as pro-inflammatory molecules with regard to acute and chronic inflammation and atherosclerosis  and are strongly suspected to be associated with inflammatory diseases, e.g., rheumatoid arthritis . LysoPCs transport fatty acids, phosphatidylglycerol, and cholines between different tissues, but also activate signaling pathways leading to the release of second messengers  as ligands for G protein-coupled receptors . Thus, they are able to promote the release of pro-inflammatory factors in endothelial cells – an important mechanism in the development of arteriosclerosis . Interestingly, population-based studies revealed inverse associations between lysoPC 18:1 and 18:2 with the risk of developing T2DM  or the onset of coronary heart disease . Given that a chronic inflammatory environment is a hallmark of such diseases, our observation of an inverse association with hsCRP potentially further argues for a functional implication of lysoPCs in the mediation between inflammation and associated diseases. The latter might be further supported by the missing effect of the exclusion of latent diabetic subjects on the observed associations between lysoPC 18:1 and 18:2 and hsCRP levels.
3’-sialyllactose as a novel link to inflammation
The urinary metabolite 3’-sialyllactose showed the strongest association and was positively related to all investigated traits. 3'-sialyllactose belongs to the group of oligosaccharides, which are generally components of milk and have a protective, immune-modulating influence on the development of neonates [49, 50]; 3'-sialyllactose is composed of sialic acid (N-acetylneuraminic acid) and lactose . Interestingly, even urinary sialic acid levels rose under inflammatory conditions, particularly in respect to fibrinogen levels but also to hsCRP within the present study. Sialic acid forms the outer end of the sugar branches representing the glycocalyx [52, 53] and exerts influence on immune reactions in different ways . Briefly, sialic acid takes part in the development of B and T cells [54, 55] and plays a role in the interaction of immune cells with other cells . The diapedesis of leucocytes  is mediated by cellular adhesion molecules with selectins and sialic acid representing important components of ligands, which can bind to the selectin family of the cell adhesion molecules. A positive relation between sialic acid and hsCRP was reported among 48 patients with chronic cardiac insufficiency, and the authors postulated both as reliable markers of systemic inflammation in chronic heart failure patients . Moreover, sialic acid appears to be a pro-inflammatory marker not only in the case of chronic cardiac insufficiency, but also in other cardiovascular diseases such as deep venous thrombosis , T2DM , and the T2DM-associated sequelae diabetic nephropathy . These findings are in good agreement with the positive association of sialic acid or 3'-sialyllactose and hsCRP in our study. As already mentioned with respect to the lysoPCs, even the association with 3-siallylactose was not affected by the exclusion of latent diabetic subjects and thus might point towards elevated 3-siallylactose levels as a preceding event. More astonishing is the discrepancy with the above-mentioned protective, immune-modulating effects of 3'-sialyllactose in neonates [49, 50]. It would be conceivable that the immune-promoting, anti-inflammatory effects of 3'-sialyllactose are only effective in newborns whose immune systems are still developing, whereas in adults, apparently the exact opposite effect is achieved. This situation should be further investigated through intervention studies.
Similarities and difference between inflammatory surrogates
The strong differences observed in the metabolic signatures for each of the inflammatory traits must be discussed. All markers were of different specificity for the inflammatory process and, from a statistical point of view, were only moderately intercorrelated (Additional file 1: Figure S3). With respect to an acute inflammatory response, CRP, fibrinogen, and WBC belong to different stages of the acute phase response with different temporal patters of accumulation [62, 63]. However, the present study focused on a low-grade inflammatory state characterized by mildly elevated hsCRP, WBC, or fibrinogen levels. The difference between hsCRP and WBC may be due to their different origins and roles during a chronic inflammatory response. CRP (and fibrinogen) are produced and secreted by the liver upon IL-6 stimulation and subsequently reach the site of inflammation through circulation. Even leucocytes reach the inflammatory site through circulation following release from the bone marrow. However, the inflammatory state of, for example, adipose tissue, in the course of low-grade inflammation is not primarily due to newly arriving immune cells but rather due to the polarization of resistant macrophages secreting cytokines, such as IL-6, which in turn stimulate the liver to secrete, among others, CRP. In conclusion, the differing metabolic profiles observed reflect the distinct physiological roles of the parameters. Even though the latter might be obvious, our results further argue for a distinct discussion of a low-grade inflammatory state dependent on the markers used to define it. The prominent role of CRP might thereby most likely be due to its long half-life, the highly sensitive assay applied, and its non-specific nature reflecting multiple distinct processes.
With respect to the different association profiles of all considered markers the unique positive relation between WBC and the carbohydrates lactate and pyruvate might be of particular interest. Lactate is known to accumulate at sites of inflammation , not only due to hypoxic conditions forcing the switch to aerobic glycolysis, but also to meet the general demands of the highly proliferative immune cells. Moreover, lactate itself was recently shown to modulate the pro-inflammatory response of T cells . Importantly, lactate induced the trapping of T cells at the site of inflammation and thus the persistence of pro-inflammatory signaling.
A predictive metabolic signature
Random forest analyses revealed a good capacity of the metabolome to predict an advanced inflammatory state. Within this signature, four metabolites were clearly distinguished as they were robustly included in the final classifier independently of the subpopulation used. The possible relation between lysoPC 18:1 and urinary 3’-sialylactose has already been discussed in the previous sections. C-mannosyltryptophan is a product derived from the C-glycosylation of the aromatic amino acid tryptophan and mannose. Previous studies noted a strong age-dependency of plasma C-mannosyltryptophan [65, 66], likely due to its strong dependency on renal filtration [67, 68]. However, neither age nor eGFR emerged as comparable predictive variables in the classification procedure. In the context of inflammation, it might be of interest that C-glycosylated tryptophan can also be found in IL-12 and components of the complement system . However, all of these studies refer to plasma levels of C-mannosyltrytophan and, even if these were also associated with hsCRP within the present study, the possible interplay of kidney function and inflammation warrants further investigation given the pronounced association observed in urine.
A note on the applicability of our findings
The comprehensive metabolic picture of low-grade inflammation drawn in the present study is useful for different kinds of research. Our results add a subclinical inflammatory state as an important determinant of the metabolome, which has to be considered in future metabolomics studies not only to avoid artificial findings but also to interpret metabolic patterns observed. The latter is of particular interest as metabolomics is a rather young scientific branch and the knowledge about its modulators is still incomplete. Further, key metabolites discussed and presented here are valuable targets for future studies to improve the diagnosis and treatment of inflammatory-associated diseases. Moreover, those metabolites might further provide molecular links between a low-grade inflammatory state and metabolic disease as small molecules are increasingly recognized as mediators in disease progression .
Strengths and limitations
An undeniable strength of our study is the combination of a large sample size, the comprehensive profiling of the metabolome, and the measurement of three clinically important inflammatory parameters. All participants were apparently healthy with respect to acute inflammation. Thus, we were able to (1) confirm previous findings concerning known associations, (2) gain deeper insights in the broad field of metabolomics, and (3) give recommendations for new possible markers indicating low-grade inflammation. However, it must be mentioned that, due to the cross-sectional design of our investigation, no conclusions can be drawn about the causalities of the found associations. Intervention studies are necessary to investigate the metabolic fingerprint of inflammation causally. Additional studies should be performed profiling the metabolic signatures of other established inflammatory markers, such as IL-6 or TNF-α, in order to augment the acquired findings, in particular with respect to the remission of inflammation. As our study addressed a low-grade inflammatory state in particular, further studies in cohorts of patients suffering from inflammatory disease, e.g., arthritis or chronic pancreatitis, are required to judge the clinical usefulness of the presented metabolic markers of inflammation. With respect to possible bystander effects, we could not rule out hidden mediation not captured by the data obtained for the study population.
We were the first to investigate the metabolic profile of an apparently healthy sample of the general population regarding its association with three clinically important representatives of inflammatory parameters. We observed an extensive picture of various associated plasma and urine metabolites, among them classical representatives of inflammation, e.g., the bradykinin system. Importantly, we were able to describe novel metabolites that were not yet investigated with regards to their connection with inflammation such as 3’-sialyllactose; these may prove potential, novel non-invasive biomarkers for low-grade inflammatory processes. As the link between metabolism and inflammation is an understudied phenomenon , our study suggests promising biomarkers for the actions of hsCRP, WBC, and fibrinogen on metabolism, which promise potential support in diagnosis and prognosis. Further, a preventive aspect might be of interest, for example, as shown for the inverse relation between glutamine and hsCRP, which was attenuated by glutamine supplementation. Similar strategies may be possible for other central metabolites named in the present study.
estimated glomerular filtration rate
high-sensitivity C-reactive protein
nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy
Study of Health in Pomerania
type 2 diabetes mellitus
white blood cell count
Kapoor S, Fitzpatrick M, Clay E, Bayley R, Wallace GR, Young SP. Metabolomics in the Analysis of Inflammatory Diseases. In: Roessner U, editor. Metabolomics, Chapter 11. Rijeka (HR): InTech; 2012.
Fitzpatrick M, Young SP. Metabolomics--a novel window into inflammatory disease. Swiss Med Wkly. 2013;143:w13743.
Hotamisligil GS, Erbay E. Nutrient sensing and inflammation in metabolic diseases. Nat Rev Immunol. 2008;8(12):923–34.
Ridker PM. From C-reactive protein to interleukin-6 to interleukin-1: moving upstream to identify novel targets for atheroprotection. Circ Res. 2016;118(1):145–56.
Ridker PM. C-reactive protein and the prediction of cardiovascular events among those at intermediate risk: moving an inflammatory hypothesis toward consensus. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2007;49(21):2129–38.
Chung GE, Yim JY, Kim D, Kwak MS, Yang JI, Chung SJ, Yang SY, Kim JS. Associations between white blood cell count and the development of incidental nonalcoholic fatty liver disease. Gastroenterol Res Pract. 2016;2016:7653689.
Honda T, Uehara T, Matsumoto G, Arai S, Sugano M. Neutrophil left shift and white blood cell count as markers of bacterial infection. Clin Chim Acta. 2016;457:46–53.
Lee CD, Folsom AR, Nieto FJ, Chambless LE, Shahar E, Wolfe DA. White blood cell count and incidence of coronary heart disease and ischemic stroke and mortality from cardiovascular disease in African-American and White men and women: atherosclerosis risk in communities study. Am J Epidemiol. 2001;154(8):758–64.
Nakanishi N, Yoshida H, Matsuo Y, Suzuki K, Tatara K. White blood-cell count and the risk of impaired fasting glucose or type II diabetes in middle-aged Japanese men. Diabetologia. 2002;45(1):42–8.
Lohsoonthorn V, Dhanamun B, Williams MA. Prevalence of metabolic syndrome and its relationship to white blood cell count in a population of Thai men and women receiving routine health examinations. Am J Hypertens. 2006;19(4):339–45.
Johnson AR, Makowski L. Nutrition and metabolic correlates of obesity and inflammation: clinical considerations. J Nutr. 2015;145(5):1131S–6S.
Ha CY, Kim JY, Paik JK, Kim OY, Paik YH, Lee EJ, Lee JH. The association of specific metabolites of lipid metabolism with markers of oxidative stress, inflammation and arterial stiffness in men with newly diagnosed type 2 diabetes. Clin Endocrinol (Oxf). 2012;76(5):674–82.
Heemskerk MM, Giera M, Bouazzaoui FE, Lips MA, Pijl H, van Dijk KW, van Harmelen V. Increased PUFA content and 5-lipoxygenase pathway expression are associated with subcutaneous adipose tissue inflammation in obese women with type 2 diabetes. Nutrients. 2015;7(9):7676–90.
Jha JC, Jandeleit-Dahm KA, Cooper ME. New insights into the use of biomarkers of diabetic nephropathy. Adv Chronic Kidney Dis. 2014;21(3):318–26.
Liu J, Wang C, Liu F, Lu Y, Cheng J. Metabonomics revealed xanthine oxidase-induced oxidative stress and inflammation in the pathogenesis of diabetic nephropathy. Anal Bioanal Chem. 2015;407(9):2569–79.
Volzke H, Alte D, Schmidt CO, Radke D, Lorbeer R, Friedrich N, Aumann N, Lau K, Piontek M, Born G, et al. Cohort profile: the study of health in Pomerania. Int J Epidemiol. 2011;40(2):294–307.
Inker LA, Schmid CH, Tighiouart H, Eckfeldt JH, Feldman HI, Greene T, Kusek JW, Manzi J, Van Lente F, Zhang YL, et al. Estimating glomerular filtration rate from serum creatinine and cystatin C. N Engl J Med. 2012;367(1):20–9.
Evans AM, DeHaven CD, Barrett T, Mitchell M, Milgram E. Integrated, nontargeted ultrahigh performance liquid chromatography/electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry platform for the identification and relative quantification of the small-molecule complement of biological systems. Anal Chem. 2009;81(16):6656–67.
Budde K, Gok ON, Pietzner M, Meisinger C, Leitzmann M, Nauck M, Kottgen A, Friedrich N. Quality assurance in the pre-analytical phase of human urine samples by (1)H NMR spectroscopy. Arch Biochem Biophys. 2016;589:10–7.
Liaw A, Wiener M. Classification and regression by randomForest. R news. 2002;2(3):18–22.
Maurer M, Bader M, Bas M, Bossi F, Cicardi M, Cugno M, Howarth P, Kaplan A, Kojda G, Leeb-Lundberg F, et al. New topics in bradykinin research. Allergy. 2011;66(11):1397–406.
Kaplan AP, Joseph K. Pathogenic mechanisms of bradykinin mediated diseases: dysregulation of an innate inflammatory pathway. Adv Immunol. 2014;121:41–89.
Cugno M, Agostoni P, Brunner HR, Gardinali M, Agostoni A, Nussberger J. Plasma bradykinin levels in human chronic congestive heart failure. Clin Sci (Lond). 2000;99(5):461–6.
Natarajan SK, Muthukrishnan E, Khalimonchuk O, Mott JL, Becker DF. Evidence for pipecolate oxidase in mediating protection against hydrogen peroxide stress. J Cell Biochem. 2017;118(7):1678–88.
Straub RH, Cutolo M. Glucocorticoids and chronic inflammation. Rheumatology (Oxford, England). 2016;55 Suppl 2:ii6–ii14.
Djurhuus CB, Gravholt CH, Nielsen S, Mengel A, Christiansen JS, Schmitz OE, Moller N. Effects of cortisol on lipolysis and regional interstitial glycerol levels in humans. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab. 2002;283(1):E172–177.
Neshich IA, Kiyota E, Arruda P. Genome-wide analysis of lysine catabolism in bacteria reveals new connections with osmotic stress resistance. ISME J. 2013;7(12):2400–10.
Renz H, von Mutius E, Brandtzaeg P, Cookson WO, Autenrieth IB, Haller D. Gene-environment interactions in chronic inflammatory disease. Nat Immunol. 2011;12(4):273–7.
Slack E, Hapfelmeier S, Stecher B, Velykoredko Y, Stoel M, Lawson MA, Geuking MB, Beutler B, Tedder TF, Hardt WD, et al. Innate and adaptive immunity cooperate flexibly to maintain host-microbiota mutualism. Science (New York, NY). 2009;325(5940):617–20.
Shu XL, Yu TT, Kang K, Zhao J. Effects of glutamine on markers of intestinal inflammatory response and mucosal permeability in abdominal surgery patients: a meta-analysis. Exp Ther Med. 2016;12(6):3499–506.
Yeh CN, Lee HL, Liu YY, Chiang KC, Hwang TL, Jan YY, Chen MF. The role of parenteral glutamine supplement for surgical patient perioperatively: result of a single center, prospective and controlled study. Langenbecks Arch Surg. 2008;393(6):849–55.
Richard V, Dahiya D, Kaman L, Raj P, Behera A. Effect of perioperative glutamine administration on C-reactive protein and liver function tests in patients undergoing hepatic resection. Pol Przegl Chir. 2014;86(1):11–6.
Melis GC, ter Wengel N, Boelens PG, van Leeuwen PA. Glutamine: recent developments in research on the clinical significance of glutamine. Curr Opin Clin Nutr Metab Care. 2004;7(1):59–70.
Ellis AC, Patterson M, Dudenbostel T, Calhoun D, Gower B. Effects of 6-month supplementation with beta-hydroxy-beta-methylbutyrate, glutamine and arginine on vascular endothelial function of older adults. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2016;70(2):269–73.
Ligthart-Melis GC, van de Poll MC, Boelens PG, Dejong CH, Deutz NE, van Leeuwen PA. Glutamine is an important precursor for de novo synthesis of arginine in humans. Am J Clin Nutr. 2008;87(5):1282–9.
Tong BC, Barbul A. Cellular and physiological effects of arginine. Mini Rev Med Chem. 2004;4(8):823–32.
Potenza MA, Nacci C, Mitolo-Chieppa D. Immunoregulatory effects of L-arginine and therapeutical implications. Curr Drug Targets Immune Endocr Metabol Disord. 2001;1(1):67–77.
Al-Dirbashi OY, Al-Hassnan ZN, Rashed MS. Determination of homocitrulline in urine of patients with HHH syndrome by liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry. Anal Bioanal Chem. 2006;386(7-8):2013–7.
van Waardenburg DA, de Betue CT, Luiking YC, Engel M, Deutz NE. Plasma arginine and citrulline concentrations in critically ill children: strong relation with inflammation. Am J Clin Nutr. 2007;86(5):1438–44.
Piton G, Manzon C, Monnet E, Cypriani B, Barbot O, Navellou JC, Carbonnel F, Capellier G. Plasma citrulline kinetics and prognostic value in critically ill patients. Intensive Care Med. 2010;36(4):702–6.
Packard CJ, O'Reilly DS, Caslake MJ, McMahon AD, Ford I, Cooney J, Macphee CH, Suckling KE, Krishna M, Wilkinson FE, et al. Lipoprotein-associated phospholipase A2 as an independent predictor of coronary heart disease. West of Scotland Coronary Prevention Study Group. N Engl J Med. 2000;343(16):1148–55.
Suzuki T, Solomon C, Jenny NS, Tracy R, Nelson JJ, Psaty BM, Furberg C, Cushman M. Lipoprotein-associated phospholipase A(2) and risk of congestive heart failure in older adults: the Cardiovascular Health Study. Circ Heart Fail. 2009;2(5):429–36.
Lp PLASC, Thompson A, Gao P, Orfei L, Watson S, Di Angelantonio E, Kaptoge S, Ballantyne C, Cannon CP, Criqui M, et al. Lipoprotein-associated phospholipase A(2) and risk of coronary disease, stroke, and mortality: collaborative analysis of 32 prospective studies. Lancet. 2010;375(9725):1536–44.
Schmitz G, Ruebsaamen K. Metabolism and atherogenic disease association of lysophosphatidylcholine. Atherosclerosis. 2010;208(1):10–8.
Fuchs B, Schiller J, Wagner U, Hantzschel H, Arnold K. The phosphatidylcholine/lysophosphatidylcholine ratio in human plasma is an indicator of the severity of rheumatoid arthritis: investigations by 31P NMR and MALDI-TOF MS. Clin Biochem. 2005;38(10):925–33.
Zhao J, Liang Y, Song F, Xu S, Nian L, Zhou X, Wang S. TSG attenuates LPC-induced endothelial cells inflammatory damage through notch signaling inhibition. IUBMB Life. 2016;68(1):37–50.
Wang-Sattler R, Yu Z, Herder C, Messias AC, Floegel A, He Y, Heim K, Campillos M, Holzapfel C, Thorand B, et al. Novel biomarkers for pre-diabetes identified by metabolomics. Mol Syst Biol. 2012;8:615.
Stegemann C, Pechlaner R, Willeit P, Langley SR, Mangino M, Mayr U, Menni C, Moayyeri A, Santer P, Rungger G, et al. Lipidomics profiling and risk of cardiovascular disease in the prospective population-based Bruneck study. Circulation. 2014;129(18):1821–31.
Eiwegger T, Stahl B, Schmitt J, Boehm G, Gerstmayr M, Pichler J, Dehlink E, Loibichler C, Urbanek R, Szepfalusi Z. Human milk--derived oligosaccharides and plant-derived oligosaccharides stimulate cytokine production of cord blood T-cells in vitro. Pediatr Res. 2004;56(4):536–40.
Newburg DS, Ruiz-Palacios GM, Morrow AL. Human milk glycans protect infants against enteric pathogens. Annu Rev Nutr. 2005;25:37–58.
Mudd AT, Salcedo J, Alexander LS, Johnson SK, Getty CM, Chichlowski M, Berg BM, Barile D, Dilger RN. Porcine milk oligosaccharides and sialic acid concentrations vary throughout lactation. Front Nutr. 2016;3:39.
Varki A. Glycan-based interactions involving vertebrate sialic-acid-recognizing proteins. Nature. 2007;446(7139):1023–9.
Varki A. Sialic acids in human health and disease. Trends Mol Med. 2008;14(8):351–60.
Van Dyken SJ, Green RS, Marth JD. Structural and mechanistic features of protein O glycosylation linked to CD8+ T-cell apoptosis. Mol Cell Biol. 2007;27(3):1096–111.
Wuensch SA, Huang RY, Ewing J, Liang X, Lau JT. Murine B cell differentiation is accompanied by programmed expression of multiple novel beta-galactoside alpha2, 6-sialyltransferase mRNA forms. Glycobiology. 2000;10(1):67–75.
Crocker PR, Paulson JC, Varki A. Siglecs and their roles in the immune system. Nat Rev Immunol. 2007;7(4):255–66.
Nourshargh S, Alon R. Leukocyte migration into inflamed tissues. Immunity. 2014;41(5):694–707.
Rajendiran KS, Ananthanarayanan RH, Satheesh S, Rajappa M. Elevated levels of serum sialic acid and high-sensitivity C-reactive protein: markers of systemic inflammation in patients with chronic heart failure. Br J Biomed Sci. 2014;71(1):29–32.
Reganon E, Vila V, Martinez-Sales V, Vaya A, Mira Y, Ferrando F, Aznar J. Sialic acid is an inflammation marker associated with a history of deep vein thrombosis. Thromb Res. 2007;119(1):73–8.
Yilmaz G, Yilmaz FM, Aral Y, Yucel D. Levels of serum sialic acid and thiobarbituric acid reactive substances in subjects with impaired glucose tolerance and type 2 diabetes mellitus. J Clin Lab Anal. 2007;21(5):260–4.
Roozbeh J, Merat A, Bodagkhan F, Afshariani R, Yarmohammadi H. Significance of serum and urine neuraminidase activity and serum and urine level of sialic acid in diabetic nephropathy. Int Urol Nephrol. 2011;43(4):1143–8.
Ho KM, Lipman J. An update on C-reactive protein for intensivists. Anaesth Intensive Care. 2009;37(2):234–41.
Bokoch GM. Chemoattractant signaling and leukocyte activation. Blood. 1995;86(5):1649–60.
Haas R, Smith J, Rocher-Ros V, Nadkarni S, Montero-Melendez T, D'Acquisto F, Bland EJ, Bombardieri M, Pitzalis C, Perretti M, et al. Lactate regulates metabolic and pro-inflammatory circuits in control of T cell migration and effector functions. PLoS Biol. 2015;13(7):e1002202.
Menni C, Kastenmuller G, Petersen AK, Bell JT, Psatha M, Tsai PC, Gieger C, Schulz H, Erte I, John S, et al. Metabolomic markers reveal novel pathways of ageing and early development in human populations. Int J Epidemiol. 2013;42(4):1111–9.
Zierer J, Pallister T, Tsai PC, Krumsiek J, Bell JT, Lauc G, Spector TD, Menni C, Kastenmuller G. Exploring the molecular basis of age-related disease comorbidities using a multi-omics graphical model. Sci Rep. 2016;6:37646.
Yonemura K, Takahira R, Yonekawa O, Wada N, Hishida A. The diagnostic value of serum concentrations of 2-(alpha-mannopyranosyl)-L-tryptophan for normal renal function. Kidney Int. 2004;65(4):1395–9.
Takahira R, Yonemura K, Yonekawa O, Iwahara K, Kanno T, Fujise Y, Hishida A. Tryptophan glycoconjugate as a novel marker of renal function. Am J Med. 2001;110(3):192–7.
Hofsteenge J, Blommers M, Hess D, Furmanek A, Miroshnichenko O. The four terminal components of the complement system are C-mannosylated on multiple tryptophan residues. J Biol Chem. 1999;274(46):32786–94.
Lotta LA, Scott RA, Sharp SJ, Burgess S, Luan J, Tillin T, Schmidt AF, Imamura F, Stewart ID, Perry JR, et al. Genetic predisposition to an impaired metabolism of the branched-chain amino acids and risk of type 2 diabetes: a Mendelian randomisation analysis. PLoS Med. 2016;13(11):e1002179.
This work was funded by grants from the German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF, grants 01ZZ0403, 01ZZ0103, 01GI0883, AtheroSysMed 03IS2061B), the Ministry for Education, Research and Cultural Affairs, as well as the Ministry of Social Affairs of the Federal State of Mecklenburg-West Pomerania. This work is also part of the research project Greifswald Approach to Individualized Medicine (GANI_MED). The GANI_MED consortium is funded by the Federal Ministry of Education and Research and the Ministry of Cultural Affairs of the Federal State of Mecklenburg-West Pomerania (03IS2061A). We would like to thank Bianca Schmick from Genome Analysis Center for expert technical assistance. A part of this study was supported by the German Center Diabetes Research (DZD e.V.) grant to JA.
Availability of data and materials
The Study of Health in Pomerania (SHIP) data are publicly available for scientific and quality control purposes. Data usage can be applied for via www.community-medicine.de.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The Study of Health in Pomerania was approved by the local ethics committee and conformed to the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki. The study was approved by the ethics committee of the University of Greifswald and conformed to the principles of the declaration of Helsinki.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Pietzner, M., Kaul, A., Henning, AK. et al. Comprehensive metabolic profiling of chronic low-grade inflammation among generally healthy individuals. BMC Med 15, 210 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12916-017-0974-6